Author's Preface
7:00 to 7:30 PM — Trick or Treat
03:56:40
In the first thirty minutes, a hundred and nineteen people learned what they were.
I don’t mean that as poetry. I mean that I watched it happen, one face at a time, the way you watch a stain spread across a tablecloth. There was a before and an after, and the line between them was about as wide as a candy wrapper. Before, Alder Street was a place where people borrowed each other’s ladders. After, it was a place where a grown man in a pirate coat could knock a sixty-eight-year-old woman onto her back and take a bowl of toothbrushes out of her arms, and half the street would see it, and nobody would run toward her.
I turned my head to look back one more time, and I have never forgiven myself for the half second I stood there.
Mrs. Dolan was down. The witch’s hat had rolled into the gutter. She lay on her side on the wet asphalt with one arm flung out and the other pressed to her ribs, and Gary Kessler stood over her with the bowl in his good hand and the plastic hook dangling from his left sleeve, cracked clean in half. He tipped the toothbrushes into his wagon, every one, and then he did something that I still cannot get out of my head. He bent down, with a little grunt, and picked up her fallen hat. He looked at it. He set it on top of the candy in the basket, carefully, like a man placing a flower.
Then he looked up and saw me looking.
He didn’t smile. He didn’t scowl. He just nodded once, with a kind of heavy, courteous patience, as if we had settled something between us, and he took up the handle of the wagon and rolled it on down Alder Street toward number twenty-two.
“Jonah.” Hazel’s hand tugged at mine. “Jonah, move .”
I moved.
7:04 PM
Sumac Court was a dead end, a short curl of road with nine houses around a patch of grass that the HOA called a green and that the kids called the Pit. It was usually the quietest part of the neighborhood. Tonight, it sounded like a riot.
Somebody was hammering on a door with something heavy. Somebody else was yelling, over and over, in a cracked tenor, “ I have a family, I have a family, I have a family ,” as though it were a spell. A garage door went up with a mechanical shriek and came down again. Glass broke. A minivan had been abandoned with its engine running and its headlights on, parked across the grass at an angle, and in the white glare the neighbors moved back and forth like figures in a shadow play, carrying things, dragging things, shouldering one another aside.
Every one of them was holding their left wrist out in front of them like a thing that might bite.
“Dess!” Wren was ahead of us, running flat out, and she had already reached the mouth of the court. “Dess, wait— wait —”
Dess didn’t wait. She had her head down and her pillowcase clutched to her chest, and she cut across the Pit without looking left or right, straight toward the last house on the left. The Dunnes’. A big brick colonial with a three-car garage and a wreath on the door that said WELCOME in plaid. The garage was open. A light was on inside.
“Kofi!”
“Dess?”
The voice came out of the garage, small and thin and far too calm, and Dess let out a breath that sounded like it had been torn out of the bottom of her.
He was sitting on an overturned bucket next to a rack of rakes. The T. rex head was in his lap. His hair stood up in damp spikes, and his green felt spines had come half unstitched, and his pillowcase sat beside him on the concrete with a neat little pile of candy in it, as though he’d been arranging it. A thirteen-year-old in a black cat-burglar outfit stood beside him with a cricket bat in both hands, held at an angle that suggested she had seen it done in a movie. Maddie Foss was as white as paper. She looked like she’d been holding that bat for twenty minutes without once putting it down.
“He wouldn’t stop looking at the sky,” Maddie said, to Dess, in a rush. “I told him to come inside, I told him, and he was just standing in the middle of the street, and then the President came on, and then—I didn’t know what to do, so I came here, Mrs. Dunne let us, she said we could hide, I’m sorry , Dess, I didn’t know—”
“It’s okay.” Dess was on her knees on the concrete with her brother’s face in both her hands. She was checking him over, hands moving along his arms, his chest, his neck, in the swift, practical sweep of a girl who had done this after a thousand scraped knees. “You did good. You did so good. Are you hurt? Kofi? Are you hurt?”
“No.”
“Did anyone touch you?”
“No.” He pulled back a little and examined her with a solemn, unnerving attention. He was eight years old, and he looked at his sister like a small judge. “They shot Mr. Pruitt.”
“I know.”
“I saw it from the Pit. There was a lot of red. Is Mr. Pruitt dead?”
“Yes, baby.”
“Okay.” He nodded, once, and picked up the T. rex head, and set it carefully on his lap again. His lip was trembling, very slightly, and he was working hard to make it stop. “I’m not going to cry, because Maddie cried and it made it worse. I’m going to be useful.”
Dess made a noise I had never heard from her. She pulled him against her chest and held on.
No one said anything for a moment. Theo had come up behind us, wheezing, with one hand clutching the foam bun at his shoulder. Priya stood in the doorway with her clipboard pressed to her sternum. Wren was breathing hard, looking out at the Pit and the milling shapes of the neighbors with her jaw working, like a dog watching a gate.
On the wrist of the small boy in Dess’s arms, I saw a thin black band, and the dim green glow of its screen.
CANDY: 22
RANK: 112 / 119
“Dess,” I said quietly.
“I see it.”
“He’s—”
“I see it, Jonah.”
She let go of him. She sat back on her heels, pulled her own pillowcase into her lap, and began to take things out of it. Carefully, one piece at a time, and not looking at anybody. A Milky Way. A handful of Starbursts. Two full-size Hershey bars. She laid them on the concrete in a row, the way you lay out bandages.
“What are you doing?” said Priya.
“Evening it out.”
“That’s—Dess, hold on, we don’t know yet if the rules—”
“It’s on his wrist. It’s in the pillowcase or on the person. It counts what the person has.” Dess didn’t look up. “So I’ll put it in his pillowcase. It will count as his. The President said that, didn’t he? It was a rule. Traded. Begged. Taken. Given. ”
She tipped the whole line into Kofi’s bag, and the band chirped. The numbers flickered.
CANDY: 71
RANK: 69 / 119
Kofi looked at the number. He looked at his sister’s pillowcase, which was flatter by half. “That’s not fair,” he said. “Now you’re low.”
“I’m not low. I’m fine . I’m the oldest one here. I’ll get more.”
“Where?”
“I’m going to take it,” Dess said, very evenly, “from whoever has it.”
There was a silence. I looked at Hazel. She was staring at Dess with her mouth slightly open, and I understood that she had never heard Dess say anything like that, because I had never heard Dess say anything like that, and in the way of a person watching a house settle on its foundation, I realized that something about us had already begun to shift.
“Dess,” said Hazel gently. “No. We’ll figure out another way.”
“There isn’t another way.”
“There is. There has to be.”
“Hazel.” Dess lifted her head at last. Her eyes were black and calm and utterly steady. “There are a hundred and nineteen of us and five of us die every half hour. Do the math. There’s no other way. Somebody has to be at the bottom, and I’m going to make sure it isn’t him.”
“I know. I just—”
“I know you know.” Her voice softened a fraction. “I love that you’re like this. I do. I need you to stay that way. But I’m not going to be.”
Hazel opened her mouth. She closed it. She sat down next to Dess on the cold concrete, her wings crumpling softly behind her, and she took one of Kofi’s small hands in both of hers.
“Okay,” she said. “Then I’ll be both.”
7:09 PM
“The candy,” said Priya.
She was standing by the door that led from the garage to the Dunnes’ kitchen, which stood slightly ajar. Her voice was strange. I’d heard that tone from her exactly once before, in sophomore chemistry, a half second before a beaker of something cracked.
“There’s candy in every home,” she said. “He said it. Enough for the evening, not enough for everyone. Come look at this.”
We crowded into the kitchen behind her.
It was a nice room, lit with soft under-cabinet lighting, the countertops covered in a film of ordinary clutter: a stack of unopened mail, a bowl of lemons, a child’s drawing held to the fridge with a magnet in the shape of a strawberry. Mrs. Dunne stood in the middle of it with her back to the island and her arms wrapped around her husband. She was a short woman with graying red hair and a cardigan the color of oatmeal. Her husband, Ray, was a head taller, a retired high-school football coach with a barrel chest and a pair of reading glasses hanging from a cord. He had a cast-iron frying pan in one hand. His knuckles were white.
“Kids,” he said, as we filed in. His voice was very quiet. “This isn’t a good time.”
“We’re sorry, Coach,” said Wren. “We’re looking for the Okafor boy. We found him. We’re going.”
“No. Stay.” It was Mrs. Dunne. Her eyes were red-rimmed and her smile was a terrible, trembling, brave thing. “Stay a minute. You’re babies. All of you. I won’t send babies out into that.” She turned to the counter and pulled something forward. “Here. Take some. Please. We’ve got plenty.”
On the island sat a gray metal case.
It was about the size of a bread box, plain and square, with a matte finish and no markings except for a small green lamp on the lid and a strip of white label across the front. It looked like something delivered in an unmarked truck. Mrs. Dunne had opened it. Inside, packed in tight rows beneath a sheet of clear plastic, lay candy. Dozens of pieces. Snickers, Milky Ways, 3 Musketeers, Twix, Reese’s, Butterfingers, every one of them in the small shiny wrappers I knew from every Halloween of my life.
Fun size.
The label read: HOUSEHOLD ALLOCATION. ALDER CT. / SUMAC 5. 3 RESIDENTS. 66 PIECES.
“They were just there ,” said Mrs. Dunne. “On the counter. When the lights came back. All the houses have one. Ray says—”
“I saw the Hendersons’,” said Ray. “The Alvarezes’. They’re all the same. All the same size.” He cleared his throat. “Sixty-six pieces. Three people. Twenty-two each.”
“That’s exactly Kofi’s number,” said Priya.
Everyone looked at her.
“His band said twenty-two,” she said slowly. “When we walked in. Twenty-two. That’s what he’s carrying . And the Dunnes have twenty-two a head.” She had stopped looking at us. Her eyes had gone wide and glassy, and her free hand was moving, tracing small sums in the air. “No. Hold on. That can’t be the whole story. It’s a different—his twenty-two came from trick-or-treating , he went out an hour before—”
“Priya.” I touched her shoulder. “What are you thinking?”
“I don’t know yet.” She shook her head quickly, like a swimmer clearing water out of her ears. “I don’t know yet. I need more data. Just— look at the allocation. Every house gets sixty-six. I mean, every house gets the same number per person . Twenty-two a head. And it’s all fun size . It’s all the little ones. Why would they—”
She stopped. She looked at her own wristband, at the green numbers on its screen, at the little black rank counter ticking quietly in the dark.
“How is it counting?” she said, very softly.
“What do you mean, how?” said Theo.
“My bag has full-size bars in it. Two of them. My Snickers and my Hershey’s. And a bunch of Smarties. A full-size bar is one piece . A Smartie is one piece . If it were counting pieces, my rank would be—” She broke off. “No, it’s not counting pieces. It’s weighing them. It has to be weighing. It’s a weighted count, it’s—”
“What does that mean?”
“It means that a full-size bar is worth more than a fun size,” said Priya. “Maybe three times. Maybe four. And your father,” she said to me, “gave you a lot of full-size bars.”
I looked down at my pillowcase. It was heavy. It was far heavier than anything else we carried. I thought of my father tipping the steel bowl, the bright gleam of the wrappers, half , and the sound my band had made, over and over.
CANDY: 212
RANK: 9 / 119
I hadn’t even looked at it before. I had been looking at his face.
“We’re rich,” I said stupidly. “Dad made us rich.”
“You’re rich,” said Wren. She had gone very still. “You’re the richest kid on the street. Jonah, you need to not tell anyone that.”
“Here,” said Mrs. Dunne, who had not been listening. She was pushing candy at Kofi, at Maddie, at Hazel, filling their open pillowcases with her small trembling hands, handfuls and handfuls of the shiny little wrappers. “Take it. Take it. It’s only candy. Ray, tell them. It’s only candy .”
“Nancy,” said Coach Dunne. “Honey. You’re giving it all away.”
“I’m giving it to children.”
“I know. I know you are.” He put down the frying pan. He wrapped both arms around her from behind, and he rested his chin on the top of her head. Over her shoulder, he looked at us. His face was the face of a man who has just seen the bottom of a very deep hole. “Go on,” he said. “Go on, kids. Go find your folks. And be careful, all right? Be careful . There’s some people out there tonight who’ve already forgotten they know you.”
7:13 PM
We left the Dunnes’ house with the lights of Sumac Court throbbing behind us, and with Maddie Foss’s mother running across the grass toward us with a face like a woman coming up from underwater.
I won’t describe the reunion. It was private, and it was brief, and Maddie was crying too hard to make sense. Her mother, who was a nurse’s aide with a bad back and a flat-brimmed work cap, scooped her up like a toddler and was gone into the dark without a word to any of us. I watched them go. I thought, one . One kid delivered. I tried to imagine how many hundred I would have to count to feel like it had mattered.
“Okay.” Priya spoke with brisk, fragile authority. “We have to get organized. There’s no time. I need us to agree on some basics before we go anywhere.”
“I’m listening,” I said.
“One. Rank isn’t everything. The cut is five. Only five. If we stay anywhere in the top ninety, we’re safe, at least at this first one. So the goal isn’t to win , it’s to not be at the bottom, and that’s a very different problem. It means we don’t need all the candy. We just need enough.”
“Enough is a moving target,” said Wren.
“I know.”
“Everybody else is doing the same math.”
“I know , Wren. I said it was a different problem. I didn’t say it was an easy one.” Priya swallowed. “Two. The five at the bottom aren’t random. They’re the people who can’t protect what they have, or who gave it away. Kids. Old people. People who don’t know how to fight. If we want to stay out of that group, we have to stay with each other, and we have to stay armed , and we have to stay quiet about what we’re carrying. Which means,” she said, with a pointed glance at me, “that nobody mentions the Snickers.”
“Three,” said Dess. “The tally is in seventeen minutes.”
That shut everyone up.
“Seventeen minutes,” Dess repeated. “I’d like to know what everyone’s going to be doing in them.”
“We stay moving,” said Wren. “We don’t sit. A moving target’s a hard target. We hit houses on the south end of Alder, where the bowls haven’t been touched, and we stay out of the middle of the street, and if anybody comes at us, I’ll—”
“You’ll what?” said Theo. “Hit them with a foam sword?”
She looked at him. Slowly, she raised the foam sword in her right fist, studied it, and with a quick hard snap, she brought it down against the corner of a mailbox, and it broke in half with a damp, squeaky crack. Underneath the foam, sticking out of the tattered end of the thing like a bone, was a three-foot length of steel pipe.
“Huh,” said Theo.
“My cousin made it,” said Wren. “For cosplay. It’s a prop. Structural.” She flexed her wrist. The pipe whipped through the air with a thin, ugly whistle. “I was always going to be the one with the real sword.”
“I love you,” said Theo, in a voice of sincere awe, “and I’m also terrified of you.”
“That’s the right order.”
It got a laugh out of us. A short one, cracked and awful and entirely real. It was the last one for a long time.
We walked back out toward Alder Street in a tight formation, with Wren at the front and Dess at the rear, holding Kofi’s hand. Priya in the middle with her clipboard. Hazel and I on the flank. Theo, ridiculous and brave, shuffling along in his hot-dog suit with his arms out like a man carrying invisible groceries. The streetlights had all gone out. The only light came from the drones above, white and steady, and from the glowing screens on our wrists, and from the porches of the houses where people stood in their doorways, holding up their bands and looking at us as we passed.
They all looked at us. That was the first thing I noticed. Every eye. They looked at our pillowcases, and then at our faces, and then at our pillowcases again.
7:16 PM
The Kessler boys were waiting for us at the corner of Birch Lane.
I saw them from half a block away, and I knew, the way you know that a dog is going to bite before it has finished lowering its head. They had arranged themselves across the middle of the road, one on either side of the Hendersons’ twelve-foot inflatable skeleton, which had finally lost its fight with the wind and lay across the lawn like a drunk. Danny Kessler stood on the left. He was seventeen, six foot two, with his father’s heavy shoulders and none of his patience, and he held a hockey stick in both hands, loosely, like a man who had held one a great deal. Colt stood on the right, fifteen, thin and fidgety, with a tire iron hanging from his fist. Neither wore a costume. They had both gotten dressed for it in dark clothes, dark hoods, gloves.
“Hey, Banks,” said Danny, pleasantly. “Nice dog.”
Theo stopped dead. The foam bun bobbed on his shoulders.
“We don’t want any trouble,” said Priya, in her best parent-teacher-conference voice. “We’re going home. We’re just going to walk past you.”
“Sure,” said Danny. “Sure, you can walk past.” He took a casual step to his left, and the hockey stick came around so that the blade hung in the air between us. “Just leave the bags.”
“Danny,” said Hazel. “Please. It’s only the first twenty minutes. We’re all just—”
“Don’t,” said Colt. His voice cracked. He was staring at the pavement, at the toes of his sneakers, at anything but our faces. “Don’t talk to us like that. Okay? Don’t talk to us like we’re people you know.”
“We do know you,” said Dess quietly. “We’ve known you since you ate paste in kindergarten.”
“Well, stop it.”
“Colt.” Danny didn’t take his eyes off us. “Shut up.”
He was an easy kid to dislike, Danny Kessler. In ninth grade he had held a boy named Avery Pohl upside down by the ankles over the edge of the bleachers, and in tenth he had stolen the principal’s golf cart. But I had never believed he was cruel. He’d been a cut-up. A dumb, loud, big-hearted jerk, who ran his mouth and laughed at his own jokes. I looked at his face now and I saw something I had never once seen there. He was scared. He was so scared that it had come around the other side of fear and turned into something flat and smooth and horrible.
“My dad says,” said Danny, “that nobody has to get hurt. If nobody makes it hard. We’ll take what we need and you can go. That’s all. Nobody needs to—it’s just business .”
“Your dad just knocked Mrs. Dolan down,” said Wren.
“She was in the way —”
“She’s sixty-eight.”
“I don’t care !” Danny’s voice cracked and went up. “I don’t care how old she is! Don’t you get it? Somebody dies ! Five people die in thirteen minutes, and I’m not—I’m not going to be one of them, and neither is my brother, and I’m not going to stand here and argue about it with a bunch of—”
He was already moving.
Wren had been moving before him.
I have gone back over the next few seconds more often than almost anything else in my life, and I still can’t put them in order. It happened in a smear. I remember the hockey stick coming round in a flat, whistling arc, aimed at Theo’s head, and Theo throwing up both foam-padded arms with a thin high shriek. I remember the sound of the stick hitting the foam, a soft, ridiculous whump , and the bun folding around it. I remember Wren’s shout, a single raw syllable, and the thing in her hand that had been a prop sword a minute before.
It was a three-foot length of steel pipe. It hit Danny Kessler’s left forearm at the speed of a car door slamming, and the sound it made was not like anything I had heard. It was a dull, wet crunch, like someone stepping on a stick under a blanket.
Danny screamed.
The hockey stick went spinning out of his hand and clattered into the street. He folded over his arm, with his mouth wide open and his eyes screwed shut, and a high thin whistling noise came out of him, a note so pure and terrible that it seemed to have nothing to do with a person. Wren stood over him with the pipe cocked back by her ear. She was breathing in long hard pulls through her teeth, and her braid had come undone, and her face had gone perfectly blank.
“Wren,” I said.
She brought the pipe down again. Not on his arm. On the pavement, beside his head, with a crack that sent a line of white chips flying. Danny flinched against the asphalt and scrabbled backward on his elbow like a crab.
“Wren!”
“I hear you.”
“Jonah!” That was Priya, shrieking. “Jonah, behind you —”
I turned. Colt Kessler was coming at me with the tire iron raised over his head, running in a long stumbling gallop, his eyes enormous and his mouth stretched wide in a silent scream. He wasn’t going to stop. I knew that from the way his feet landed. He was fifteen, and he was going to bring that thing down on my skull because he had no idea how else to stop being afraid.
I didn’t think. I did the only thing I could, which was to drop my pillowcase and throw myself forward into him.
We hit with a grunt and a clang. The tire iron skidded out of his hand and rang off the pavement, and I got my shoulder into his chest and we went down together, rolling, a blur of black sweatshirt and bedsheet and elbows. A knee hit my jaw. Something cracked in my mouth, and I tasted salt. I got one hand around his collar and the other around his wrist, and I heard myself yelling something stupid, stop, stop, stop, Colt, stop , as though he were a dog.
He went limp.
It happened all at once. One second he was thrashing and kicking and the next he lay under me on the cold road, panting, with his hood fallen back and tears running sideways across his temples into his ears. He was crying. He was crying like a little kid, openly, with his whole face, and he wasn’t even fighting me any more.
“I don’t want to die ,” he said. “I don’t want to die. Dad said we had to. He said we had to get the big ones first. He said—”
“I know.”
“He said you had the big ones. He said your dad had been putting out Snickers —”
“I know. Colt. I know.”
I let go of his collar. I rolled off him. I sat on the asphalt with my hand against my jaw and my head ringing, and across the street I watched Wren hold the pipe over Danny Kessler’s head for what felt like an hour.
“Do it,” said Danny, through his teeth. He had both eyes open now. His face was the color of putty and there were bright red tears on his cheeks. His left forearm hung at an angle that made my stomach twist. “Go on. Do it. Do it, you—”
“Wren,” said Hazel.
She hadn’t shouted. She had said it quietly, from behind, and she had put one hand very gently on Wren’s elbow.
“Wren. Look at me.”
“He was going to take Kofi’s bag.”
“I know.”
“He was going to kill him for it.”
“I know. He’s not going to now.” Hazel stepped around her, between the pipe and the boy on the ground. She was a head shorter than Wren, in a moth costume with coffee-filter wings, and she knelt down in front of Danny Kessler as if she had every right in the world to do it. “Danny. Danny, hey. Don’t move your arm. I’m going to look at it, okay? I’m not going to touch it. I just want to see.”
“Get away from me.”
“I will. In a minute.”
She looked at the arm, and then she looked up at Wren. “It’s broken. Both bones. You did it right.” Her voice was shaking, but it was level. “He’s not going to be able to swing anything for a while. Okay? You did what you had to. You can stop now.”
Wren lowered the pipe. She did it slowly, as though it had become heavy, and when it touched the ground she stood leaning on it with both hands, breathing like a runner at the end of a mile. The color was coming back into her face.
“I didn’t want to,” she said, to nobody. “I didn’t want to do that.”
“I know,” Hazel said.
“I don’t even like hitting people. I’m not—I do track, I’m not like that, I—”
“You’re not,” said Hazel. “You’re okay.”
7:19 PM
The argument started before Danny had finished crying.
He sat against the wheel of the Hendersons’ minivan with his good hand clamped around his ruined arm, and Colt had crawled over to him and pressed his own face into his brother’s shoulder. Hazel had unwound the long brown scarf she wore with her costume and was using it to bind the arm against a splint she had made from the broken hockey stick. Her hands were fast and sure. She had done this before, I realized. Or watched someone do it. Albuquerque, her mother, a hospital, a lifetime of waiting rooms.
“Take his bag,” said Wren.
She wasn’t looking at Hazel. She was looking at the street. Danny’s pillowcase had split open when it hit the ground, and a bright stream of wrappers had spilled out across the asphalt, a long glittering fan of candy that caught the white light of the drones overhead. Fun-size Snickers and Milky Ways. A hundred, two hundred pieces. Dozens of full-size bars, which I guessed were the Pikes’ and the Alvarezes’ and the Dunnes’, collected in a long hungry hour of knocking on other people’s doors.
“Wren—”
“He came at us. He broke the rules. He’s not—” She stopped and made herself breathe. “Look. I’m not saying we leave him to die. I’m saying he’s got three hundred pieces of candy and a broken arm, and he can’t carry it, and somebody’s going to take it in about thirty seconds. Why shouldn’t it be us?”
“Because it’s his ,” said Hazel.
“He was trying to take ours!”
“I know. And you stopped him. That’s enough.”
“It isn’t enough if we’re at the bottom in thirteen minutes, Hazel! They’re not giving points for being nice !”
“No,” said Hazel. “They’re not.”
She tied the scarf in a hard final knot, and Danny hissed. She stood. For a moment, she looked at all of us in turn, at Wren, at Theo sitting on the curb with his foam bun crushed under him, at Priya with her pen frozen over her clipboard, at Dess with her arms wrapped around her brother, at me, with the blood in my mouth.
“I’m not saying you’re wrong,” she said. “I don’t think you’re wrong, even. I think it makes sense. I think if I did the math, I’d come out the same place. I just—” She stopped. Her chin quivered. “He’s not the enemy . He’s a scared kid. He’s a kid we’ve known for years. If we start taking from the people who hurt us, we’ll never stop. There’s always going to be another reason. There’s always going to be somebody else who was going to take ours. That’s how it works. That’s how it works, Wren. That’s how it all—”
“That’s how what works?” said Wren.
“That’s how they win,” Hazel said.
Nobody spoke. Down the street a man was laughing, high and loose, the laugh of someone whose mind had slipped its moorings, and a woman was calling a child’s name over and over in a voice like a bird’s. The white lights of the drones turned slowly overhead.
“I don’t know what the right thing is,” I said.
It came out thick, through the swelling in my mouth. They all looked at me. I hadn’t known I was going to say it. My father’s voice was in my ear, you’re the one who holds it together , and I felt the weight of that, enormous and absurd, settling over my shoulders like a coat I hadn’t asked for.
“I don’t. I’m sorry. I think Wren’s right, and I think Hazel’s right, and I don’t know how that works. But I know this. Colt told me his dad sent them. He told them to go after me . Which means Gary Kessler knows what’s in my bag, which means we’ve got a bigger problem than Danny.”
“Jonah—”
“I’m not done. We take back Theo’s. Only Theo’s. The bag Danny tore, the stuff they took. We don’t touch the rest. We leave it for them.”
“They’re not going to keep it,” said Wren. “Look.”
She pointed.
They were coming out of the dark.
I don’t know where they had been. Perhaps they had been standing in their doorways the whole time, watching, waiting for a verdict. Perhaps they had been drawn by the sound of the hockey stick on bone. But as I looked, three, four, then a dozen shapes were drifting out of the fog toward the glittering fan of candy on the road. They were adults. A woman in a nurse’s smock. A man in a tuxedo T-shirt. A pair of teenagers I recognized from the high school band. They walked in a loose, hesitant, shuffling crowd. They did not run. Nobody ran. They only moved forward, steadily, with their eyes fixed on the road, and then one by one they dropped to their knees on the asphalt, and began to gather.
It was the most terrible thing I had ever seen. They did not fight over it. They scooped it up in quiet, steady handfuls, in total silence, pushing it into pockets and pillowcases and the fronts of their shirts, a dozen people kneeling in a ring in the middle of a road, picking up candy like pigeons.
Danny watched them. He didn’t say anything. He looked at their bent backs, at the glitter in their hands, and I saw something go out of his face, some last small light. He turned his head away and put it down against his brother’s hair.
“We go,” I said. “Now.”
We went.
The last thing I remember from that corner is Hazel, who had bent down quietly as the others turned away and tucked something into the pocket of Danny Kessler’s hoodie. A single Reese’s cup. One. She patted it flat. She didn’t think any of us saw.
I did.
7:23 PM
“Miss? Excuse me. Miss, are you—”
It was a woman’s voice, soft and polite, in the middle of all that wreckage. It came from a porch on our left, from a small neat house with blue shutters and a stenciled welcome mat that said GOOD VIBES ONLY. Number thirty-one. A woman sat on the top step in the dark, with her elbows on her knees and her hands hanging loose between them, and a little girl in an orange pumpkin costume stood at her side with one fist wound into the hem of her coat.
“Are you the girl?” said the woman. “The moth?”
Hazel stopped.
I knew her. Not well. Rachel Ames was the dental hygienist who cleaned my teeth every six months, a tall, tired, funny woman in her thirties who hummed along to the radio while she worked and called every child champ . Her husband was stationed somewhere overseas, and she had raised Mia more or less by herself for three years with the help of a mother-in-law who lived in Dayton. She was wearing scrubs with little pumpkins on them. She had put a cardigan over the top, and I realized, with a small cold shock, that she had put on lipstick.
“Mrs. Ames,” said Hazel. “I’m so sorry—is Mia okay? Is she hurt?”
“She’s fine.” Rachel smiled. She had a lovely smile, wide and crooked, with one tooth slightly overlapping the next. “She’s doing wonderful. Mia, honey, tell the girl what you told me.”
“I have sixty-one, ” said Mia, solemnly, holding up her wrist.
We looked.
CANDY: 61
RANK: 41 / 119
“That’s a very good number,” said Priya, in a faraway voice. “That’s an excellent number for a five-year-old.”
“It’s because of Hazel,” said Rachel. “I told her. I said, that girl gave you half of her candy, and now you have a lot. That’s why. It was the nicest thing anybody’s ever done for us. Do you know that? It was the nicest thing.”
“It was nothing,” said Hazel.
“It was everything.” Rachel looked up at her, still smiling. “I did the math, you know. I’m a hygienist, not a mathematician, but I can count. I counted the minutes. I counted the houses. I counted the people who can’t keep their candy because they’re too slow or too old or too good, and I counted how much was left in the allocation. And I put every single thing I had into her bag. Everything. Every piece. All of it, and my husband’s.”
She held up her left wrist.
CANDY: 0
RANK: 119 / 119
I don’t think any of us breathed.
“Mrs. Ames,” said Priya hoarsely. “You’re—you’re last.”
“I know.”
“You’re last . At seven-thirty they—”
“I know, sweetheart.” She said it very gently. “That’s what I’m telling you. I looked at it. I looked at it very hard. If I keep any, even a few, I’m still in the bottom twenty, and she is too, probably, because she’s five and she can’t hold on to a thing if someone bigger wants it. And if I fight for it, and I lose, we both lose. And I’m not good at fighting. I’m a good dental hygienist.” She laughed, a small startled breath. “So I took the one number I could change. I made hers as high as I could make it. It’s a much better number than mine.”
“You can’t,” said Hazel. Her voice had gone very high. “You can’t do that. There has to be—we’ll give you some, we’ll—Jonah, Jonah has two hundred, he can—”
“Hazel.” Rachel reached up and took her hand. “No. Please. You’re very kind, and you’re not listening. I’ve made up my mind. I’ve had twenty minutes, and I’ve thought about every possible way, and this is the one that works.” She took a breath. “I’m asking you something instead. It’s the only thing I want. Can I ask you?”
Hazel nodded. She was crying now, silently, tears pouring down her face and dripping off her chin.
“Please take her with you.”
“Mrs. Ames—”
“Just for tonight. I know it’s a lot. I know she’s one more thing to carry, one more mouth, and I’m so sorry. I wouldn’t ask if there were anyone else. But I’ve watched you for twenty minutes. I saw what you did at the drain. And everyone else on this street is going to look at her pillowcase and think sixty-one .”
She turned to Mia and pulled the little girl into her lap. Mia went without protest. She put one small hand against her mother’s cheek, and Rachel kissed her palm.
“Baby,” she said. “Mommy has to stay here and do some grown-up work.”
“What kind of work?”
“The boring kind. You know. Paperwork. You’re going to go with the moth.”
“Are you coming?”
“Later.”
“How much later?”
“A little.” She smoothed back the felt stem of the pumpkin hat. “You be good. You be so, so good, and you hold her hand, and you do whatever she says. And when you’re scared, you count to ten. Like we do.”
“One, two, three,” said Mia.
“That’s right.”
“Four. Five.”
“That’s my girl.” Rachel put her forehead against her daughter’s, and closed her eyes. “That’s my brave girl.”
I looked away.
I looked at the porch rail. At the doormat. At the plastic pumpkin on the steps, empty, its mouth grinning in the dark. At anything. It was a cowardly thing to do and I did it, and I will carry it forever, the way you carry a stone in a shoe.
When I looked back, Hazel had Mia in her arms.
She had picked her up as easily as if she’d done it all her life. The little girl’s arms were around Hazel’s neck, her legs wrapped around her waist, and the glowing wings had folded around both of them in a soft brown bell. Rachel had stood, one hand on the rail. She smoothed her cardigan. She wiped her face briskly with the back of her wrist, the way you do when you’re late for something.
“Thank you,” she said.
“I’ll keep her safe,” said Hazel. “I swear. I swear on—I promise. Whatever happens. I’ll keep her.”
“I know you will.”
She didn’t say anything else. She went up the steps, and sat down in the porch chair, and took off her shoes, and set them side by side. She folded her hands in her lap. She looked, I thought, exactly like a woman who has come out to sit on her porch on a warm night to watch the stars.
“Go,” she said, smiling. “Go on. It’s getting late.”
The numbers on my wrist read 03:34:16, and I understood that we had five minutes.
7:27 PM
Our porch light was still dark.
It sat there above the door of number fourteen like a dead eye, and my father stood under it on the top step with the steel bowl at his feet and his arms folded across his chest. He had been standing there, I think, for ten minutes. He saw us come around the corner of the Hendersons’ hedge, five kids and a small boy and a little girl in a pumpkin hat, and I watched his whole body uncoil.
“There,” he said. It came out of him like a sigh. “There you are. There you are.”
He came down the steps in two strides and caught me against his chest. For a second, I just let him. I stood there with my face pressed into his shirt, which smelled of sweat and cardboard and the faint leftover sweetness of eleven hundred candy bars, and my whole body shook in quick, hard, silent jolts, like something being hammered.
“You’re bleeding,” he said into my hair.
“It’s my lip.”
“Who did it?”
“Colt Kessler.”
“Did you—”
“I’m okay. Dad. I’m okay. We’re all okay. Everyone’s okay.”
“Everyone?” He pulled back. His eyes ran over them, counting: Wren with her pipe, Theo with his torn foam suit, Priya, Dess with her hand clamped over her brother’s shoulder, Hazel, and the child in her arms. His eyebrows drew together. “Who’s this?”
“This is Mia,” said Hazel. She said it steadily. “She’s with me.”
“Hi, Mia.” My father crouched. He had a way of crouching that put him at a child’s eye level without seeming to lower himself, a teacher’s trick, and I had never loved it more. “I’m Mr. Pike. Jonah’s dad. I like your hat.”
“It’s a pumpkin.”
“It’s the best pumpkin I’ve seen all night.”
“My mommy’s doing paperwork.”
My father looked at Hazel, and then at me, and I watched him understand. It crossed his face like the shadow of a cloud. He was a man who had spent twenty-two years reading the faces of teenagers across a classroom, and he did not need it explained. He rose slowly. He put a hand on Mia’s head, so gently it hardly seemed to touch her, and then he took his hand away, and looked up the street.
One hundred yards off, at the top of the slope, stood the little house with the blue shutters. I could just make out a figure sitting on the porch.
“Rachel,” said my father, very low.
“She made me promise,” said Hazel.
“I know.” His voice cracked. “I know she did. She would.”
“Dad. The tally is—”
“I know. I know. Okay.” He shook himself, as a dog shakes off water, and when he turned back to us he was my father again, brisk and gentle and in command. “Okay. Everybody. Check your numbers, and tell me. Quickly. Don’t read it out loud if you’re scared. Just look.”
We looked.
Mine said RANK: 9 / 119. Priya’s said 71, and Wren’s said 44. Theo had climbed back to 80 after we collected his scattered haul from the road. Dess was at 69, and Kofi, whom she had loaded like a donkey with Mrs. Dunne’s gifts, at 63. Hazel stared at the screen on her own wrist for a long moment. RANK: 77 / 119.
Mia was at 41.
“Every one of you is safe,” said Priya. Her voice shook. “Every one of us. For the first one. The cut is going to be anybody below a hundred and fourteen. We’re all well above it.”
“That’s good,” said my father. “That’s good. That’s good.” He said it three times, the way you say something to convince yourself it isn’t a lie. His own band read RANK: 22 / 119 . He had kept a little less than half of the Snickers.
Then the whole neighborhood fell silent.
It happened in a wave. It started a long way off, I think, from the far end of Sumac Court, and rolled up Alder Street like a tide coming in. The shouting stopped. The crying stopped. The man who had been laughing in the road, the one whose laugh had gone slack and wrong, stopped between one breath and the next. Forty-one dark houses, and all around them, in the doorways and the driveways and the middle of the road, a hundred and fourteen people stood still, and held up their wrists, and waited.
00:01:12 , said my band. Then 00:01:11.
Hazel had turned Mia’s face into her shoulder and was holding the back of her head. Mia was whispering. I could barely hear her. “ One, two, three. ”
“Who do you think they’ll—” said Theo, and stopped.
“Don’t,” said Dess.
“I just want to know—”
“There’s no knowing . Shut up. Please. Just stand here.”
I looked at my father. He was standing with one arm out, his hand spread on the small of my back, and his gaze was fixed on a point somewhere down the hill. He was moving his lips. I thought he might be praying. I realized, after a while, that he was counting too.
7:30 PM
It came as a sound first.
A high, clear, sustained tone. Not loud. It rose from our wrists, from all the wrists on the street at once, a single bright note pitched somewhere between a doorbell and a smoke alarm. Every screen went white. Then it settled, and three words appeared, centered, in black.
TALLY COMPLETE.
The drones above us moved.
Every one of them seemed to tilt, a minute, synchronized shifting, like a flock of starlings turning in the sky. Then the lights came on. Not the soft white eyes of before, but great blazing cones of light, as bright as stadium floods, stabbing down out of the dark. One. Two. Three. Four. Five.
They landed on people.
I saw them all at once, and for the rest of my life I will see them all at once. Five white pools on the black street, evenly spaced, like footlights, and in each one a small figure, standing very straight.
In the first, at the top of the hill, was a woman in a cardigan, sitting in a porch chair with her shoes set neatly side by side.
In the second, a few yards from the Hendersons’ dragon bowl, stood a wiry old man in a white T-shirt and suspenders, holding an empty pillowcase against his chest. It was Augustin Feeney, who was ninety-one, who had been a tailor and a widower and the oldest living resident of Alder Street, and who was deaf as a post and had not, I realized, heard a single word the President said.
In the third, on the sidewalk, in his pajamas, a short stout man with a gray mustache and a very surprised expression stood with both his hands out, palms up, in front of a gaggle of little children, who stared at him with their mouths open. They were holding fistfuls of candy. Tomás Alvarez, the fog machine man. I learned afterward that he had spent his last twenty minutes pouring every piece of his allocation into the bags of other people’s kids.
In the fourth, a heavyset old woman in a witch’s hat was lying on her back in the middle of the road where Gary Kessler had left her.
She wasn’t dead. She was sitting up, very slowly, with one hand pressed to her ribs, and she was looking directly at the sky. I saw her mouth moving. I saw her chin lift. And I heard, across a hundred yards of silence, in a voice that had put the fear of God into thirty-one years of schoolchildren, the last words of Dolores Dolan.
“ Well, this is certainly a poor way to run a bus. ”
In the fifth, in the doorway of a house I knew by heart, in a wheelchair that had stopped on the ramp, with a blue afghan across her knees, sat Dorothy Pruitt. She had not moved since she put on her band. She was looking at the place in the road where her brother lay.
A voice came out of the sky.
It was the same flat, cheerful, female voice. It did not shout. It read the names in an even and tender tone, in order, the way a teacher reads the roll.
“ Rachel Ames. Augustin Feeney. Tomás Alvarez. Dolores Dolan. Dorothy Pruitt. ”
A pause.
“ Thank you for your service to the future. ”
From somewhere above us, very faint, came a soft patter of applause.
I will never forget that sound. It came from the speakers on the drones, from a thousand little membranes in the dark, and it was scattered and gentle and polite, a sound like rain beginning, and under it, thin and bright and quite distinct, came the clink of ice against glass.
Then the bands began to hum.
I saw it begin on the first of them, on the woman in the cardigan at the top of the hill. The black strap on her left wrist lit up red from end to end, as if someone had drawn a line of blood around it. She looked down at it with polite interest. She lifted her wrist to her face, as though to read the time. And then I saw it spread. A fine black thread of ink ran out from under the strap and up the pale inside of her forearm, branching, forking, racing for her elbow in a lacework of dark veins. It reached her shoulder. Her mouth opened. Her whole body jerked once, upright and rigid in the chair, and her eyes filled up with red, and she lowered her arm into her lap, and put her other hand over it, and bent her head.
That was all. Ten seconds. I counted. I couldn’t help it. I stood on my own front lawn and counted, and I heard a tiny voice at my elbow counting too.
“ Seven. Eight. Nine. ”
Hazel had put her hand over Mia’s other ear. She was whispering into the child’s hair. “That’s right, baby. Keep going. You’re doing so good. Keep counting. Don’t stop.”
“ Ten, ” said Mia.
In the pool of white light at the top of the hill, the woman in the cardigan did not move. She sat with her chin on her chest and her hands in her lap, and her stocking feet resting on the boards, and she looked as though she had fallen asleep on her porch on a summer evening.
And then the street began to scream.
Not all at once. It was a raggedness. A flicker. Down by the Hendersons’, old Mr. Feeney had dropped to one knee and then onto his side, in a long, slow, undignified fold, his suspenders twisted across his back. His mouth was moving in a clear ragged rhythm, forming a word, over and over, Anna, Anna, Anna , and I realized it was a name, and I realized that no one would ever know whose. The fog machine man had collapsed in the middle of his small audience. A dozen children stood in a ring around him, staring down at their sneakers. One of them, a boy of maybe seven, in a cardboard robot suit, knelt and put a single piece of candy in Mr. Alvarez’s open hand.
Dorothy Pruitt died without a sound. She simply slumped to one side against the arm of her chair, with her eyes still on the road. For a moment I thought she was smiling.
Mrs. Dolan was the last. She had been sitting up straight in her pool of light, bolt upright, with her crooked hat and her chin high, like a woman on a platform waiting for a train. The black thread reached her heart. I saw her hands open. I saw her look down, with an expression of great and puzzled dignity, at the red band on her wrist, and I heard her say, quite distinctly:
“ Oh, for heaven’s sake. ”
She toppled backward, slowly, into the street.
The floodlights clicked off.
I don’t know how long we stood there.
No one told us to move. No one told us anything. In the first seconds of the dark, a thick, ringing quiet fell over Alder Street, and in it I heard small sounds: a child being sick in the grass. A man crying, with great gasping breaths, like a person coming up from the bottom of a pool. The soft tick of rotors as the drones tilted back to their stations. A mother’s voice, quite calm, saying, over and over, It’s all right. It’s all right. It’s all right.
It was Hazel’s voice.
She was still holding Mia. She had sunk down onto the porch step, with the pumpkin hat crushed between her cheek and the child’s head, and she was rocking, back and forth, back and forth, her wings dragging on the boards. I don’t think she knew she was talking. The fairy lights had gone out on one side. Mia lay against her without moving, wide-eyed and limp, a small orange weight, and I saw the child’s lips still forming numbers, one, two, three, four, although no sound came.
My father had gone gray. His hand, on my back, was trembling so hard I could feel it through my shirt. I thought: he knew them. He had known every one of them for twenty years. Mrs. Dolan had once come to our door with a casserole when Mom left, and had stood on the step with her arms crossed and said, Don’t you dare say thank you, Marcus, I’m not doing it for you, I’m doing it for the boy.
“Dad,” I said.
“I’m here.”
“Dad. They’re—”
“I know.”
“Mrs. Dolan—”
“I know , Jonah.” He said it thickly, and then he did something I had never seen him do. He pressed the heel of one hand hard against his eyes and held it there. “Okay,” he said. “Okay. Let me—give me a second. Let me think.”
“You don’t have to be—”
“Yes, I do.” He took the hand away. His eyes were red-rimmed and wet and terribly clear. “That’s exactly what I have to be. It’s the only job I’ve got left.”
He straightened up. He looked at each of us in turn, one by one, as though memorizing us. Then he spoke very quietly, in the voice he used when somebody in his shop had lost a finger and had to be walked to the car.
“Here is what we do. They said eight tallies. That was one. We have a half hour before the next. Your numbers are good, but they won’t stay good, because they’ve just taken five people off the bottom, and the line moves up. The next five are going to be the people who can’t keep what they have. So the bottom is going to get hungry. People will go for the next easy thing, and then the next. Don’t be the next easy thing. Stay together. Stay off the main road. Never trade with anybody unless you can see both their hands.”
“Dad—”
“I’ll be on Birch. Mrs. Henderson’s got the twins, and Walt’s hurt his back, and somebody has to—I’ll check on them. I’ll be back here by eight.” He took my face in his hand. “The porch. You remember?”
“The porch.”
“The light doesn’t work.”
“I know.”
“Don’t come looking for me if I’m late.”
“Dad.”
“Jonah.”
I nodded.
“Good,” he said. He kissed my forehead, and then, because he was a man who did not believe in leaving the things that mattered unsaid, he added, “I’m proud of you. I’m so proud of you. I want you to hear that now, in case.”
“Don’t say in case .”
“I won’t say it again.”
He picked up the steel bowl, and he went. I watched him go down our walk and out into the street, a thin stooped man in a gray sweater, carrying a mixing bowl full of candy bars through a field of dark. He never looked back. I think he knew he couldn’t.
The band on my wrist chirped, once.
I looked down, and the numbers had changed. The old ones were gone. There was a new clock, bright and green and ticking.
00:29:41
And beneath it, a new line.
REMAINING: 114
RANK: 7 / 114
“We’re safe,” said Priya, in a hollow voice, from somewhere behind me. “We’re all safe. For now. For thirty minutes.” She was staring at her clipboard. Her pen hung loose in her fingers. On the first page, in neat blue ink, she had made a column of figures, and I saw that she had crossed out the name at the bottom of it with a single hard, trembling line. “Thirty-nine,” she said. “Thirty-five more of us die tonight.”
“Priya.”
“I’m just saying. That’s thirty-five.”
“We know,” said Wren.
“I know you know. I just—I have to say the number. I have to say it, or I’m going to—” She put her hand over her mouth. Her shoulders heaved once. Then she took it away, and wiped her eyes with the heel of her palm, and lifted her chin, and I saw the old, fierce, stubborn girl who had once corrected a substitute teacher’s grammar until he left the room. “There’s something wrong with it,” she said. “The allocation. The numbers. Something about the way it’s built . I don’t know what. I need a minute and a pen and a place to sit.”
“We’ll find you one,” I said.
“Thank you.”
She didn’t move. None of us did. We stood in the front yard of number fourteen on a cold, bright October night, five teenagers, a small boy, and a child in a pumpkin hat, in a ring on the dark grass, beside three plastic tombstones and a hedge strung with fake webs. I looked at the pumpkins on my father’s porch. The skull. The perfect fanged grin. The third one, the lopsided one, the one we’d carved with our eyes closed, which still wore its crooked, stupid, happy face.
The candle in it had gone out.
A long way down Alder Street, something began to squeak.
It was a thin, dry, rhythmic sound, a wheel in need of oil, and it moved slowly and without hurry through the dark. I knew it before I turned. Every one of us did. We turned together, all seven of us, and looked down the hill.
In the cold white shadow of the drones, a red wagon was rolling up the center of the road. A large man walked behind it with the handle in his fist and his coat swinging about his knees. He stopped beside the first of the bodies. He looked down at the old tailor, curled on his side with his suspenders twisted. He bent, with a small, tired grunt, and he picked up the empty pillowcase from the old man’s fingers, and shook it out, and folded it, and laid it in the basket.
He went to the second. Then the third.
He was very careful. He was very, very polite. At every stop, he touched the brim of his hat.
Then Gary Kessler lifted his head, and he looked up the hill, across a hundred yards of dark and fog and corpse-light, at the porch of number fourteen. At us. I couldn’t see his face. I could only see the shape of him, wide and still, with the wagon beside him and the white hat of a dead woman riding on top of the candy.
He raised one hand, and he waved.
On my wrist, the clock ticked down.
00:28:57.
End of Chapter Two
Comments