Author's Preface
7:00 PM — Selected
The last normal thing my father did on Halloween was argue with a porch light.
It was a quarter past six, the sky over Alder Street fading to the color of a healing bruise, and he was up on the second rung of the stepladder with a bulb in one hand and the other braced against the gutter, saying things to the socket that he would never have said in front of his students. Marcus Pike taught shop at Marrow Creek High. He could cut dovetail joints in his sleep and rebuild a carburetor from a diagram on a napkin, but electricity, he maintained, held a personal grudge against him.
“It’s the fixture,” he said. “It’s not the bulb. The bulb is fine. The bulb has always been fine.”
“Dad, it’s a porch light.”
“It’s a porch light on Halloween.” He aimed the bulb at me like a gavel. “A dark porch on Halloween is a declaration of war, Jonah. Do you know what the Kessler boys do to a dark porch?”
“Egg it.”
“Two years ago they hit the Wilsons with a carton and a half. I counted the shells.”
“You counted the shells.”
“Somebody had to.”
I was sitting on the top step with a bedsheet in my lap. I had cut two eyeholes in it with kitchen scissors, and that was the entire extent of my costume and, in my opinion, the entire extent of my obligation. Theo had bet me a month of lunches that I couldn’t get through October without a costume he approved of. I had bet him a month of lunches that a sheet counted. It was a classic. It was the original. He had called it “a hostage situation with no hostage,” and we had agreed to let Priya judge, because Priya was the only one of us who could be trusted to hold a grudge and a standard at the same time.
Dad twisted the bulb home, and the porch lit up yellow-white. The light fell across the yard like something spilled: the fake cobwebs he’d stretched over the hedge, the plastic tombstone with the joke on it that only he thought was funny ( I TOLD YOU I WAS SICK ), and the three pumpkins we’d carved the night before at the kitchen table. Mine was a skull that had gone wrong somewhere around the nose and looked more like a startled potato. His was perfect, a fanged grin, symmetrical down to the tooth. The third we’d done together with our eyes closed, as a joke, and it looked like it had been hit by a truck. That one was my favorite.
“Fixture,” Dad said again, to no one, and climbed down with the satisfied slowness of a man who has won an argument against an inanimate object.
On the porch table sat the bowl. It was our biggest steel mixing bowl, the one Mom had taken out of every kitchen drawer for twenty years of Thanksgivings and then, in the end, left behind when she went to Tucson. Dad had filled it to the brim, and not with the little stuff. Full-size candy bars. Snickers, Kit Kats, Reese’s cups in the orange packaging that made you feel like you’d won something. Every year the neighbors teased him about it, and every year he gave the same speech.
“Fun size,” he said now, and tapped the rim of the bowl with a knuckle. “You know what I’ve never understood? Fun for who? It’s a smaller candy bar. That’s all it is. It’s a regular candy bar that somebody took a bite out of and sold you the rest of, and they put a smiley word on the wrapper so you won’t notice.”
“You say this every year.”
“And every year it’s true.” He sat down next to me on the step and was quiet for a moment, rolling the dead bulb between his palms. “Your mother called while you were in the shower.”
“Okay.”
“She wants a picture of the costume.”
“It’s a sheet.”
“She’ll love it. She’s going to tell everyone at her office her son is a ghost.” He glanced sideways at me. “You know you’re taller than me now?”
“Since August.”
“I’m making a note of it.”
“Why are you being weird?”
He thought about that with the seriousness he gave everything, which was one of the things I loved about him and one of the things that made it impossible to get away with anything. “I’m not being weird,” he said. “I’m being sentimental. It’s the one night a year the whole street looks like it’s having a good time, and I’m allowed to notice it. Look at that.”
I looked.
Alder Street, in the last of the daylight, was doing what it did best. Forty-one houses on three streets (Alder itself, the little hook of Birch Lane, and the dead-end curl of Sumac Court) all packed so close together that on a summer night you could hear every one of your neighbors’ arguments and every one of their barbecues. The Hendersons had a twelve-foot inflatable skeleton on their roof that was losing the fight with the wind and kept folding at the waist as though it were bowing. Mr. Alvarez had a fog machine going on his lawn, and the fog rolled out low across the sidewalk and made the little kids shriek and run through it in both directions. Somebody was playing the Monster Mash from a speaker, which was against the unwritten laws of the block, and somebody else was already yelling at them to turn it down. Two doors over, Mrs. Dolan, who had driven a school bus for thirty-one years and had opinions about all of it, sat on her porch in a witch’s hat with a bowl of toothbrushes, daring the world to say something.
“She’s going to get egged,” I said.
“She’s been getting egged since 1998,” said my father. “It’s a form of respect.”
That was Marrow Creek. A town of eleven thousand people, a Dairy Queen that closed on Labor Day, a water tower somebody had painted to look like a jack-o’-lantern in 1987 and nobody had ever repainted. It was a place you were supposed to want to leave, and I’d spent most of my sophomore year assuming I would. But I stood up on the step, with the sheet in my hand and the smell of fog fluid and cut grass and somebody’s burning leaves, and I felt it settle in my chest, a kind of stupid, helpless fondness that I would not have admitted to if you had paid me.
Then my phone buzzed, and it was Theo, and the fondness went right out of me.
THEO: where r u
THEO: i am a hot dog
THEO: i am standing in your street as a hot dog and no one has looked at me
“Go,” said my father. “Go be young. Be back for the Count.”
“We always are.”
“I know.” He smiled at me, and it was a small, crooked smile, and I think about it more than I think about almost anything. “I’ll hold the fort.”
They were waiting at the curb, and for a second I just looked at them, the way you only do when something is about to change and some animal part of you already knows.
Theo Banks stood in the middle of the sidewalk in a foam hot-dog costume, the bun puffed around his shoulders, a long squiggle of felt mustard running down the front of him. His arms stuck out of the sides at an angle that made him look like he was permanently about to hug someone. “Behold,” he said. “A dirty-water dog. A gas-station roller dog at two in the morning. I contain multitudes. I’m all of you, if you think about it.”
“You’re a hot dog,” said Wren.
“I’m the hot dog.”
“You’re a sausage in a pillow.”
“I’m art , Wren.”
Wren Castillo was dressed as a Valkyrie and hated it. She’d been voted into it. Wren was the fastest girl in our grade at anything that involved running and the angriest about anything that didn’t, and the horned plastic helmet sat on her dark braid like a joke she was waiting for someone to laugh at so she could break their wrist. She carried a foam sword in one hand with the slouch of a person who knew exactly how much better she would be with a real one. “I’m not wearing this stupid thing one more hour than I have to,” she said to me. “Where’s your costume?”
“I’m wearing it.”
She looked at the sheet in my hand. She looked at me. “That’s a pillowcase.”
“It’s a bedsheet.”
“I don’t see it on you.”
I pulled it over my head. It dropped around me with a smell of detergent and cedar, and the world went white and narrow through the eyeholes. From inside, I heard Priya say, with the satisfaction of a person finally having the evidence she wanted, “Well, that’s certainly a ghost.”
“Judge’s ruling?”
“Technically valid.” Priya Nair was standing a little off to the side with a cardboard box over her shoulders, one side cut open, a pair of cat ears on her head and a clipboard in her hands. She had a pen tucked behind her ear. “I’m willing to accept the sheet as a costume under a very narrow reading, but I’d like it on the record that it’s lazy, and that I’m only doing this because I need the lunches to stay in circulation.”
“What are you?” I asked, pulling the sheet off again.
“Schrödinger’s cat.” She tapped the box. “I am both dressed up and not dressed up until someone observes me.”
“I observed you.”
“Then I’m dressed up. Congratulations, you’ve collapsed the wave function.”
“It’s a very good costume,” said a quiet voice from the shade of the maple tree, and that was Dess, who had been standing there so still I had actually missed her.
Dess Okafor had a way of being in a place without taking up any of it. She wore a black hoodie with a black paper mask pushed up on her forehead, a long curved beak molded out of papier-mâché, and a scatter of black feathers glued to her sleeves. A crow. She looked like she’d just landed. She was the one who noticed things, which could be irritating, because it meant that she was usually right about them, and usually right about them an hour before the rest of us understood there was a thing to notice. She stood with one hand on the shoulder of a very small tyrannosaurus rex.
“ Rrrawr ,” said Kofi Okafor, who was eight years old, and who had been made into a dinosaur by a green hoodie with felt spikes down the back and a rubber head so big it sat on him like a mailbox. “I’m going to eat the whole street.”
“Please start with Theo,” said Wren.
“Mom said I could go out with Maddie from Sumac Court,” Kofi told me, with the grave and immense confidence of a person who has secured a very specific permission. “Only on the streets and only until it’s dark and Dess has to check on me every—” He frowned. “Every something.”
“Every half hour,” said Dess. “And we’re walking you over to Maddie now.”
“Why?”
“Because I said so.”
“That’s not a reason.”
“It’s the best reason there is.” Dess looked up at me over his rubber head, and for a second I saw the tiredness around her eyes, the look of a girl who had been a second mother since she was eleven. Her father drove long-haul and was gone three weeks out of four. Her mother worked at the hospital in the next county and picked up double shifts to keep the house. Dess raised Kofi the way some people raise a garden, patiently, mostly alone, and with no illusions about the weather.
“We’ll all go,” I said.
“Don’t make a thing of it.”
“I’m not making a thing of it.”
“You’re making a thing of it with your face.”
Someone coughed politely, and all five of us turned.
Hazel Moreno was coming up the sidewalk from the corner of Birch Lane, trying to walk carefully, which was the problem, because she was wearing the most delicate thing any of us had ever seen. She was a moth. She’d made it herself, I knew, over about three weeks of evenings, and I knew because for the last two of those weeks she’d been texting me photos of the progress with captions like WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE GLUE and tell me honestly if this is deranged . The wings were built on a frame of bent wire and covered in coffee filters that she’d dyed with tea, stained a hundred shades of brown and cream and gold, the veining drawn in with thin brown marker, and woven through the whole thing were strings of tiny white fairy lights. They glowed softly in the dusk, like something that had just crawled out of a forest. She wore a fuzzy brown sweater and two pipe-cleaner antennae on a headband. Her eyes were enormous with the effort of not being nervous.
“I’m late,” said Hazel.
“You’re not late,” said Priya.
“I’m a little late. I had to redo one of the wings, the glue was—”
“Hazel,” said Theo, with an expression of religious awe, “you’re beautiful , and I hate you, because I’m a hot dog.”
She laughed. It was a good laugh, a surprised one that came out before she could stop it, and it made something in my chest loosen that I hadn’t known was clenched.
Hazel had moved to Alder Street three weeks ago, in the middle of a Wednesday, from Albuquerque, and she’d been enrolled at Marrow Creek High by that Thursday. Her mother was a pharmacist who had taken a job at a hospital in Columbus that came with a long drive and a hundred new problems. Hazel had been dropped into our grade with no friends and no map, and she’d sat down in the back of AP Stats next to Priya, who stared at her for eight minutes with total suspicion before Hazel offered her a piece of gum, and then everything went the way it goes. By Friday, Theo had adopted her. By the following Monday, she was eating lunch with us. By the end of the second week, I’d realized I was looking for her in the hallway the way you look for a window in a stuffy room.
She was new, and she was good at it. She asked questions and listened to the answers. She laughed at Theo’s bad jokes, but not too much, so you could tell it was real. She’d noticed Dess’s quiet and never tried to fill it up. She had a way of saying no, tell me more , and then actually wanting more. We had been, I realized, a closed circle for a very long time. Five years of inside jokes and shorthand add up to a wall that you don’t see until someone new walks up to it. Hazel hadn’t knocked the wall down. She had just stood next to it until it forgot it was a wall.
“Did you explain it to her?” Wren asked me.
“Explain what?”
“The Count.”
“Oh. No, I—”
“You didn’t explain the Count.” Wren turned to Hazel with the solemn air of a coach delivering a briefing. “Okay. Here’s how it works. Every Halloween since sixth grade, the four of us go out and we get as much candy as possible. At the end of the night, everybody goes back to Jonah’s and dumps their haul on the living room floor. Priya has a spreadsheet.”
“I have a rigorous spreadsheet,” said Priya.
“Priya weighs it, counts it, and assigns a market value to every kind of candy.”
“Reese’s are five points. Full-size bars are eight. Smarties are point-two, because they’re an insult.”
“And at the end of it all,” Wren said, “somebody wins, and somebody loses, and the loser buys pizza.”
“Who wins?” Hazel asked.
There was a pause.
“Wren,” said Theo, and Priya, and I, all at once.
“Three years running,” said Wren, with a smile like a drawn knife.
“Because she steals,” Theo added.
“It’s not stealing if it’s strategy.”
“It is, actually, though.”
“Can I play?” said Hazel.
She said it quickly, and I realized how much she wanted it, how hard she’d been trying all night not to ask. Dess met my eye. Wren grinned. Priya uncapped her pen with a click.
“You’ll need a pillowcase,” said Priya, “and a strategy, and a clear understanding that you will lose.”
“I don’t mind losing.”
“Nobody minds losing,” Priya said. “They just do it badly.”
“Please,” said Theo, “stop talking about losing. You’ll jinx the whole night. It’s Halloween! The only way to lose Halloween is to not be a hot dog.” He thrust his arms out and spun, taking out a decorative cornstalk from the Millers’ lawn.
We laughed. All of us. The streetlights flickered on above the maples, one by one, the way they did every evening, and the sky over the cornfields went the deep clear blue of a thing about to turn black. It was 6:31 by my phone. I know because I looked.
I have thought a great deal since then about how much I had left of that. It was twenty-nine minutes.
Alder Street on Halloween was not a place you walked through. It was a place you waded.
By the time we’d walked Kofi to the corner of Sumac Court and handed him over to a small and dignified thirteen-year-old named Maddie Foss, who was dressed as a cat burglar and took her babysitting extremely seriously, the sidewalks had filled with kids. Princesses and Spider-Men. A boy in a full cardboard robot suit marching down the center of the road like a very small tank. A pack of toddlers dressed as pumpkins, tomatoes, and one inexplicable lobster, all of them herded by parents with cups of cider and the glazed, contented look of people at the end of a long week. Porches glowed orange. Fog crept. A father in a banana costume was shouting “ Okay, who wants a banana! ” at a child who clearly did not.
Every house had a bowl.
That was the thing I noticed, in the way you notice something just before it matters. Forty-one houses, forty-one bowls. Sometimes a cauldron, sometimes a plastic pumpkin, sometimes a salad bowl someone had rinsed out for the occasion. The Hendersons had theirs inside the mouth of a papier-mâché dragon. The Alvarezes had a coffin. Mrs. Dolan, in her witch’s hat, held her bowl of toothbrushes across her knees and said to every kid who passed, “Brush twice a day,” in the tone of a person who would be remembered when the rest of us had been forgotten.
“Why do you even do this?” Wren asked her.
“Because I love children,” Mrs. Dolan said, “and I hate their teeth.”
We cleared Birch Lane in twenty minutes. My pillowcase was an old Spider-Man one that I’d been using since second grade, and it was getting heavy in the satisfying, lopsided way of a bag that had been well used. Wren’s was already half full, and she had a look in her eye. Priya had stopped to log something on her clipboard twice. Theo was trading Starburst for Skittles with a small girl in a ladybug costume on terms I could only describe as predatory.
“It’s a market,” he told me. “She wants red. I have excess red.”
“You’re scamming a ladybug.”
“I’m facilitating liquidity .”
On the corner by the Kesslers’ place, a figure was coming down the middle of the street toward us, pulling something behind him, and the crowd moved to either side to let him through. I noticed it the way you notice a person who walks like he owns the road.
Gary Kessler was forty-four years old. He was a big man, wide through the neck and shoulders, with a graying beard and small, patient eyes, and he drove a salt truck for the county in winter and did something with gutters in the summer. He had two sons, Danny and Colt, who were seventeen and fifteen, and who threw eggs at everything and ran from everything else. He was dressed, this year, as a pirate: a tricorn hat, a red bandanna, a plastic hook where his left hand should be, and a long black coat that was almost certainly from a Halloween store. Behind him he pulled a red Radio Flyer wagon, and in the wagon was a laundry basket, and in the laundry basket was a mountain of candy.
It was ridiculous. It was a grown man, trick-or-treating, with a basket . But the thing about Gary Kessler was that nobody laughed. Whatever he asked for, from whoever he asked, he was always the first on the street to knock and the last to leave, and people handed things over to him a little too easily, a little too quickly, the way you pay a man at the door of a bar who has already looked at you for a little too long.
“Evening, kids,” he said as he passed, and tipped his hat with his hook.
“Evening, Mr. Kessler,” said Priya, because her parents had raised her to say it.
He didn’t slow. His eyes moved over each of us. Over our bags. Over, I thought, Hazel’s: the fat round bulge of it, hanging from her hand.
“Good haul,” he said, to no one in particular, and kept going.
“That man,” said Wren, once he was out of range, “gives me the creeps.”
“He’s harmless,” said Dess.
“Is he?”
“He’s never done anything,” said Dess slowly, “but I always think he’s counting.”
I didn’t say anything. I looked back over my shoulder, and the red wagon was still going, rolling slowly along the center of the road, the basket of candy swaying behind him, and Gary Kessler’s head was turning from porch to porch, house to house, in a long, slow, methodical arc. I don’t know why I remember that so clearly. I think it’s because it was the last time in my life I looked at that man and saw only a weird guy in a pirate costume.
It was 6:44 when we heard the crying.
It came from the end of the block, from the storm drain at the corner of Alder and Birch, and it was a small sound, the particular wailing of a child who has lost something that cannot be replaced. We turned. A little girl, no more than five, in a lumpy orange pumpkin costume with a green felt stem on her hat, was kneeling at the curb with both hands pressed to a rusty iron grate. Her pillowcase lay on its side. Candy was scattered across the asphalt, a few lonely wrappers spinning in the breeze. And one by one, with a faint rattle as each hit the water below, the rest of it was going down.
“No, no, no—” She was a small thing, and she’d put her whole arm through the bars as far as it would go. “It fell, it fell , my—”
Hazel was already moving.
She went down on one knee beside the girl, the wings folding and rustling behind her, the fairy lights quivering on their wires. She said something quiet. The girl looked up at her with a face red and swollen from crying and a little afraid of the giant moth. Hazel said something else, and the girl looked down at her empty bag. And then Hazel opened her own pillowcase, a fat, heavy, beautiful pillowcase, an hour and a half of work, and she poured half of it into the girl’s.
Not a handful. Half. A cascade of full-size bars and Reese’s and Twizzlers, and the little girl’s eyes went round as dinner plates.
“There,” Hazel said. “Is that okay? I think a pumpkin should have at least some candy. It’s kind of the whole job.”
The girl nodded. Then, in a movement so quick it surprised both of them, she threw her arms around Hazel’s neck and squeezed, crushing a wing, and Hazel just laughed and said “Oof,” and hugged her back.
“Mia!” A woman was running down the block, a mother with the particular terror of a person who had looked away for four seconds. “Mia, I told you not to—oh, thank you, thank you, oh my God. Mia, say thank you.”
“Thank you,” said Mia, from the depths of the moth.
“You’re welcome,” said Hazel. “Happy Halloween.”
When she rejoined us, her pillowcase hung loose and half-empty at her side, and she was smiling, and none of us said anything for a second.
“That,” said Priya at last, scribbling on her clipboard, “was a net loss of approximately four hundred points.”
“Priya.”
“I’m just noting it.”
“She’s five,” said Hazel. “Her whole night was in that gutter.”
“I’d like it on the record,” said Theo, “that I was about to do that.”
“You were not,” said Wren.
“I was about to hold the door open for it. Emotionally.”
Hazel was laughing again, and I was laughing too, and the five of us stood on the corner in the soft orange dark, with fog curling around our ankles and the whole bright street murmuring behind us. It struck me that I was happy. I want you to understand that, because everything else in this story is going to make it hard to believe. For about nine more minutes, I was just a sixteen-year-old kid with a sheet in his pocket and four friends, and the new girl was looking at me, and she smiled, and I thought: this is going to be the best Halloween we ever have.
“So I figure,” said Hazel, “I’m at a disadvantage in the Count, so I need to catch up. Is Sumac Court worth it? I heard the people at the end give out whole bags of chips.”
“The Dunnes,” said Wren. “Full-size chips. Sometimes the big ones.”
“Then let’s—”
Her phone buzzed. At the same moment, mine did.
And Priya’s. And Theo’s, and Dess’s, and Wren’s, a rolling pulse of vibration through five pockets, followed by a thousand in the street around us, a ripple of buzzing and chiming from porches and strollers and the back pockets of every parent on Alder Street. All at the same instant. All with the same tone: a long, low, bell-like sound that wasn’t any ringtone I knew. Down the block, a man in a Frankenstein mask dug in his coat and stared down at his screen. The mother with Mia stopped in the road. The fog machine at the Alvarezes’ coughed and went quiet.
I pulled out my phone.
The screen was black. In the center, in plain white letters, were four words.
YOU HAVE BEEN SELECTED.
I remember what I thought, which was nothing. It was just a feeling, a clean, high ringing in my head, as though someone had struck a glass. I looked up from the phone and the street was exactly the same. The same orange porches. The same fog. A kid in a cardboard robot suit was still marching along the center of the road. But the sound was wrong. The Monster Mash had cut off mid-chorus. The shrieking had stopped. Every person on Alder Street was standing perfectly still, looking at a rectangle of light in their hand.
Then the birds went silent.
I hadn’t noticed them until they stopped. The thousand little sounds of an Ohio evening: starlings, the distant dogs, the cicada hum that hangs on in October, the soft insect noise of a field. All of it went out at once like a switch thrown.
“Jonah,” said Priya, in a very small voice. She wasn’t looking at her phone. She was staring past me, at the horizon beyond the rooftops, out where the corn began and the last green light was bleeding out of the sky. “Jonah. Look.”
I turned around.
It looked, at first, like stars. A scatter of white lights rising from behind the tree line, in the east, in the south, in the west. A few dozen. Then a few hundred. They climbed at an unhurried, impossible angle, silent and blinking, the way fireflies rise out of a field in June. And they kept coming. Hundreds became thousands. They rose from every part of the dark horizon, and the sky above Marrow Creek filled with them. A swarm. An ocean. A glittering ceiling of tiny white eyes, every one of them turning, slowly, to look at us.
“Those are drones,” said Dess.
“It’s a light show,” said Theo, quickly. “It’s, uh, it’s a Halloween thing, the town probably, the Chamber of Commerce—”
“Theo.”
“—paid for a really big—”
“ Theo. ”
He stopped. He looked at me. For once, he had nothing.
The first one dropped down out of the glittering cloud and passed over our heads, so low I felt the wind of it on my face. It was black and flat and about the size of a pizza box, with four quiet rotors and a ring of small, steady lamps. It had a single glass eye in its belly. It paused above the corner of Alder and Birch. The eye turned, taking in the intersection, the five of us, the mother, the girl in the pumpkin suit.
It blinked.
And across Alder Street, from one end to the other, forty-one porch lights went out.
The dark lasted perhaps five seconds. It was the longest dark of my life.
People began to talk then, in the low, rising, nervous murmur of a crowd that does not yet know whether to laugh. Doors opened up and down the block. Parents came out onto porches with their drinks still in their hands. Mrs. Dolan stood up from her chair and said, loudly, “Well, that is not funny,” to the sky in general. Somewhere a toddler started to wail.
Then the drones came down.
Not the one above us, but the great glittering mass of them, a hundred, a thousand, sliding out of the high dark into lower, tighter formations. They came in silence, apart from the soft wind of their rotors, and they spread out in a wide, deliberate ring around the whole neighborhood. I watched them go over the rooftops of Sumac Court. I watched them pass the Dairy Queen sign in the distance and the black bulk of the water tower. They hovered, forty feet up and evenly spaced, and as each one settled into place a thin red light bloomed from its underside and reached sideways to find its neighbor. A line. A fence made of light, drawn right down the middle of the night, cutting through backyards and across Route 9 and along the reservoir and out into the corn.
We were inside it. All of us. All of Alder Street, Birch Lane, and Sumac Court.
Then the rest of the drones, the ones still high above us, began to move in on one another. They slid together like the pieces of a puzzle, row by row, until the sky over our heads was no longer a swarm but a surface, a vast flat curved pane of tiny lights, a hundred feet across. It hung above the intersection of Alder and Birch like a ceiling. And the lights shifted, and brightened, and became something else.
It was a face.
It was enormous, and it was calm. A man in his late fifties, with silver at the temples and a lined, patient, kind face. He wore a gray cardigan over an open-necked shirt and a pair of reading glasses pushed up into his hair. A fire crackled in a stone hearth behind him. There were books on the shelves, a lamp, a half-finished cup of tea at his elbow. He looked like a favorite uncle. He looked like a man you would trust with your dog.
Every person on Alder Street knew who he was.
“Good evening, Marrow Creek,” said President Calloway Voss.
His voice came from a thousand small speakers, a warm baritone with a faint rasp in it, perfectly clear. It filled the street like water filling a bowl.
“First, I owe you an apology,” he said. “I’m sorry to interrupt your evening. I know what this night means to your children. I have grandchildren myself, and I know exactly what I am taking from you, and I do not take it lightly.”
“This is a prank,” said Mrs. Dolan. She said it loudly, to the whole street, in her school-bus voice. “That is a deepfake . Somebody’s grandson is going to be in a great deal of trouble.”
Nobody answered her.
“You have heard of the Population Relief Act,” said the face. “Everyone has. It has been the law of our country for six years, and you have been told many times what it is and what it is for. I will not insult you by repeating the speeches. I will say only this. The planet we live on cannot hold us all. The water, the air, the soil, the heat. I have decided to say that aloud, in public, rather than leave it for someone with less courage to say after the damage is done. Every year, on this night, one place in America is asked to carry a small part of that burden for the rest of us. This year, that place is yours.”
Someone, somewhere behind me, made a sound like a cough.
“Pell Lake,” whispered Priya.
She was standing very close to me. Her clipboard hung from her hand and her cat ears had slipped over one eye, and she was staring at the sky with an expression I had never seen on her before, a kind of terrible, clinical focus.
“Last year,” she said. “Wyoming. Pell Lake. And before that, Harbor Glen, Maine. Dunmore, Iowa. It was on the news. It was always on the news. They show the — afterward, they show the —” She stopped. Her mouth was working. “There are nineteen thousand five hundred incorporated places in America,” she said. “The odds are one in nineteen thousand. It’s not supposed to be us. We’re a town , we’re nobody, nobody ever—”
“Priya,” said Wren, quietly, and took her hand.
“A town of eleven thousand people is more than the Relief can use,” said President Voss, as if he had heard. “So we choose a single neighborhood, also by lot. You are the residents of Alder Street, Birch Lane, and Sumac Court. A hundred and nineteen of you. The lights you see around you mark a boundary. The rest of Marrow Creek has been informed, and they will not be permitted to approach it. I’m afraid the line is not a request.”
The red fence hummed above the rooftops, steady and bright.
“I would like to tell you the rules,” the President said gently. “They are simple. I have always believed that if a thing must be done, it should at least be done clearly.
“In a moment, you will each be given a pillowcase and a wristband. You will put the band on your left wrist. It will lock, and it will not come off. From the moment it locks, you will have four hours. Seven o’clock until eleven.
“There is one thing in this game that matters, and it is candy.
“The band counts whatever you carry, in the pillowcase or on your person, by number and by weight. Every thirty minutes it will tally. At each tally, the five people in your neighborhood holding the least will be relieved of their place.”
He said the word relieved with a small, grave, regretful tilt of his head, the way a doctor says passed .
“That is eight tallies,” said the face. “Eight times five. Forty. When the clock reaches eleven, those who remain will go home, and they will be thanked. Their debts will be forgiven. Their children’s educations will be paid. They will be the most honored people in America, and they will spend the rest of their lives knowing what they did for the future.
“The candy may be earned. It may be traded. It may be begged for. It may be taken. There is candy in every home on your streets, and I assure you there is enough for the evening, though, I am sorry to say, not enough for everyone. I did not make the world this way. I am only trying to be honest about it. Your band will show you where you stand at all times. I believe in transparency.
“You will notice that I have not listed what you may not do to one another. I won’t insult you with that, or myself. There are only three things you may not do. You may not remove your band. You may not cross the light. And you may not stop.”
He took off the reading glasses that had been pushed into his hair and folded them, slowly, in his hand.
“There are also those who are watching,” he said. “I won’t pretend otherwise. The people whose generosity makes this work possible have asked to be present, and I have found over the years that it is easier to ask a nation to look at a hard thing if it can see the faces in it. They will see yours. I’m sorry. I would spare you that too, if I could.”
Hazel’s hand found mine. I didn’t see her reach for it. I just felt it, small and cold and gripping hard, and I held it back with everything I had.
“This is not a game of cruelty,” said the President. “There are no cruel men on this stage. The cruelty belongs to arithmetic. I am only the one who has the courage to read the numbers out loud.”
“He’s lying,” said Dess, so softly I almost didn’t hear it. “He’s lying. Look at his hands.”
I looked. The President’s hands were folded calmly in his lap, the glasses in one of them. I couldn’t see it. But I saw the thumb, slowly rubbing the lens, back and forth, back and forth, the only part of him that moved.
“One more thing,” said the President, and for the first time he smiled, a tired, warm, genuinely rueful smile that was the worst thing I had ever seen. “The people who make candy, I’m told, have a word for the little ones. The ones that come ten to a bag. They call them fun size. I’ve always found that charming. A small thing can be enough, if you have enough of them. I hope you will each find that you have enough.
“Thank you for your service to the future. Happy Halloween.”
The face dissolved. The great lit pane in the sky broke into a thousand pieces and fell away, and the lights were only drones again, black machines in a black sky, turning slowly in the dark like the wheel of some enormous clock.
For a long moment, nobody on Alder Street moved.
I have tried, since then, to describe that silence to people who weren’t there, and I never get it right. It wasn’t quiet, exactly. A baby was crying on Birch Lane. Somebody’s dog had started barking again, a thin hysterical yapping from behind a closed door. The wind pulled at the plastic skeleton on the Hendersons’ roof. But the people were silent, a hundred and nineteen of them standing in doorways and driveways and on the cold wet asphalt in costumes, a pirate and a banana and a witch and a lobster, every one of them with a face like a stopped clock.
“He can’t,” said Theo.
Nobody answered him.
“He can’t . That’s—there are kids. There are kids here. He’s the President . He can’t just—”
“Theo,” said Dess.
“He said it was a game , he—”
“Theo.” She had taken off her crow mask. I hadn’t seen her do it. She stood with the paper beak crushed in one fist, and her face was very still. “He can. He is. Stop talking, and breathe.”
He breathed. It came out of him in a long, shuddering whine, and the foam hot dog heaved around his shoulders, and he put both mustard-striped arms across his stomach and bent over. For a second I thought he was going to be sick. He wasn’t. He just stayed there, bent double in the middle of the sidewalk, and Wren put one hand on the back of his neck and held it there.
Then the drones came down for us.
They came one to a person. That was the horror of it, the neatness of it. The swarm didn’t dive or swoop. It simply unspooled, and from the black field of machines above, a single drone descended toward every living soul on the street, as a waiter descends toward a table. Each one hovered at chest height with a faint, polite hum. Each carried something suspended beneath it in a small mechanical claw.
A white pillowcase.
Mine came to rest a yard in front of my face. It was clean and stiff and slightly heavy, the cotton thick as canvas, with a faint, silvery sheen where the weave caught the light. Stenciled across the front, in black block letters, was a name. JONAH P. Under it, in smaller type: ALDER ST. 14.
“They knew my house number,” I said stupidly.
“They knew everything,” said Priya. Hers read PRIYA N. and she held it in both hands with a look of disgust, as though it were something dead. “They had a list . They had a list of every address in the neighborhood and every person who lives in it, and they had it months ago, they had to—they had to print these—”
She stopped. Her voice cracked in the middle of the word.
There was something inside the pillowcase. I reached in and pulled it out. A strip of black, matte, rubbery material, as long as my hand and as wide as a watch strap, with a small flat screen embedded in one end. Two thin silver prongs on the underside, like the clasp of a collar. The screen was lit a pale, unblinking green. It said:
04:00:00
Underneath, in smaller numerals:
CANDY: 0
RANK: — / 119
Every person on the street was holding one, I saw. Every face was lit by the same sickly glow from below. The little tin glow of a hundred and nineteen small screens, held up in the dark like candles at a vigil.
“Place the band on your left wrist,” said the drone in front of me.
It was a different voice from the President’s. It was flat and cheerful and female, the voice of a machine that had never once been wrong. “The band will lock automatically. Please place the band on your left wrist. You may then transfer your collected candy into your pillowcase. Candy outside the pillowcase will not be counted.”
“No,” said someone, loudly, out in the street.
It was a man’s voice, rough and cracked and furious. I knew it before I turned. It was Mr. Pruitt from the corner of Birch, who had been a plumber for forty years and a widower for six, and who lived with his sister Dorothy in a little house with a wheelchair ramp. He was sixty-three. He was dressed as nothing. He was just wearing a flannel shirt and an old Browns cap, because he had come out onto his porch to see what the commotion was and he hadn’t planned to be a part of it. He stood at the edge of his lawn with the band in his hand and a pipe wrench in the other, the one he took everywhere, the one that had been hanging off his belt for as long as I’d known him, and he was shaking.
“No,” he said. “No. I’m not—I will not . I’m sixty-three years old. I am not putting this on. I am not playing your goddamn game .”
“Mr. Pruitt,” said my father.
I hadn’t seen him arrive. He had come out of the dark at a run, with the bowl of full-size candy bars still clutched against his chest, and he stopped at the end of our walk, ten feet from me, breathing hard. His face was gray. “Walter. Walter, put the band on. Please. Put it on.”
“I won’t!” Mr. Pruitt’s voice was a shout now, and it broke on the word. “They can’t make me. They can’t—this is America , Marcus! I paid my taxes! They can’t make a man—”
The drone hovering in front of him tilted its glass eye.
“Please place the band on your left wrist,” it said.
“Go to hell.”
“Please place the band on your left wrist. This is your first notice.”
Mr. Pruitt looked at the little black band in his hand. For a second, he seemed to consider it. And then he drew back his arm, and he threw it. Not into the street. He turned and hurled it as hard as he could into the open storm drain at the end of the lawn, the same iron grate where little Mia’s candy had gone, and it went in with a clatter and a splash.
“There,” he said. He was almost laughing. “There. There . What are you going to do about—”
“This is your second notice,” said the drone, and the glass eye turned red.
I don’t know how to tell you what happened next.
I’ve told it a few times since, to counselors and to men in suits, to a woman with a notebook who didn’t write anything down, and every time I try to start at the beginning it comes out wrong. It wasn’t slow. It wasn’t dramatic. There was no warning light. There was a short, hard, flat crack , like a tree limb breaking in a cold wind, and Mr. Pruitt’s Browns cap flew straight up into the air and turned over once and came down.
He stood there a moment longer.
He was looking at me. I swear he was looking at me. He had the pipe wrench raised in one hand and an expression of mild, puzzled surprise, the expression of a man who has walked into a room and forgotten why, and there was a small neat dark hole in the center of his forehead, just above the bridge of his glasses. Then the back of his head came apart. It went out behind him in a bright wet fan, and splashed across the Hendersons’ hedge and the hood of a parked car and the fog, which turned pink.
He went down on his knees. Then onto his face. The wrench rang on the pavement, rolled twice, and lay still.
Somebody screamed.
It was a thin high scream, a child’s, and it set off another and another, a hundred voices all at once, bright and sharp and terrible. People ran in every direction, into the street, into their houses, into each other. A man dropped to his hands and knees on the Alvarezes’ lawn and vomited. Mrs. Dolan was standing perfectly still with both hands over her mouth and her witch’s hat knocked crooked on her head. The robot-suit boy was on the ground, in a wide puddle of his own spilled candy, and his mother had thrown herself over him. The man in the banana costume was just standing there, absolutely still, with one yellow arm hanging at his side.
A second drone had descended over Dorothy Pruitt, who was in the doorway of the little house, in her wheelchair, in her nightgown, with her hands clasped to her cheeks. It paused above her. A band dropped into her lap.
“Mrs. Pruitt is counted,” said the drone, in the same flat cheerful voice. “Thank you for your cooperation. Please place the band on your left wrist.”
She stared down at it. Then she put it on.
“Who else,” said Wren, softly, from somewhere beside me, “wants to be a hero.”
There was no more refusing after that.
It hurt less than I expected, and that was somehow worse.
The prongs went in with a small bright pinch, like the sting of an insect, and the strap snapped closed around my left wrist with a click I felt in my teeth. The screen flickered. The green light went amber, then green again. The band was snug and slightly warm. I tugged at it. It didn’t move. I put a thumbnail under the edge of the strap and tried to pry at the seam, and there was no seam. It felt like a part of my arm.
04:00:00
And then, as I watched, the last digit blinked, and became a 9.
03:59:59
“It’s started,” Priya said. Her voice was perfectly calm and perfectly hollow. “The clock’s running.”
The five of us stood in a small tight knot on the corner of Alder and Birch, with our bands on our wrists and Mr. Pruitt’s body lying in the road behind us, and nobody said anything for several seconds.
“Okay,” said Wren.
She was breathing through her nose, in long slow pulls, the way she did before a race. She had pushed the horned Valkyrie helmet off her head and it hung down her back by its strap. In her right hand, she still held the foam sword. She seemed not to know it.
“Okay. We can’t freeze up. If we freeze up, we lose. Everybody put your candy in the bags. Now. Put it in the bag.”
“Wren—”
“I said now .”
We did. I think we were all grateful to be told. It was a kind of mercy to have something to do with our hands. I upended my old Spider-Man pillowcase into the new white one, and a heap of candy poured out and rattled into the stiff cotton, Snickers and Twizzlers and the fat gold bars of Almond Joys that nobody liked. My band chirped, a small bright sound like a microwave.
CANDY: 91
RANK: 58 / 119
“It’s counting,” whispered Theo. He was holding his own band up in front of his face and staring at the screen. His voice was shaking. “It’s counting as it goes in. Oh my God. It’s ranking us.”
“I’m seventy-one,” Priya said. “I have eighty-three.”
“Forty-four,” said Wren. She had a hundred and thirty. She didn’t sound proud. “Dess?”
“Sixty-two,” said Dess. “Theo?”
“Eighty-eight,” he said. He made a strange noise. “I’m eighty-eight. I’m eighty-eight out of a hundred and nineteen , I’m a hot dog, I’m in the bottom—”
“You’re not,” said Priya, fast, and flatly. “That’s thirty-one from the bottom. They cull five . It’s just the start. Nobody’s even gone out yet. It means nothing.”
“Hazel?” I said.
She hadn’t spoken. She was standing slightly apart from us, with the loose fold of her pillowcase held against her chest, and the lights in her wings were quivering with a faint, steady tremor, like a heartbeat. She looked down at her band.
I saw the numbers over her shoulder.
CANDY: 34
RANK: 101 / 119
It was the half she had given to Mia. It was almost exactly half of what a girl who could do the math on the sidewalk would have had at seven o’clock, and the screen had measured it without mercy and had put her, in one cold blink, in the bottom twenty.
“I’m fine,” said Hazel quickly. “It’s fine. It’s only—it was a kid. I’d do it again.”
“Hazel,” said Priya.
“I’d do it again.”
She looked up. Her eyes were wet, and her chin was lifted, and I have never in my life seen anything braver or more frightened. “I would,” she said. “I don’t care. It’s fine . We’ll just have to get more. It’s only a hundred and one. That’s a lot. That’s a lot of people we’re doing better than.”
Nobody answered her. Wren was staring at the screen of her own band with her jaw set. Theo had stopped breathing through his mouth. Priya had her pen in her fist so hard it left a white line across her palm.
I opened my pillowcase and looked at what was in it. Ninety-one pieces. I looked at Hazel.
I couldn’t have told you what I was about to do, but I was already reaching into the bag when a hand closed hard on my arm.
“Don’t.”
It was my father.
He had come up behind me on the walk, and I hadn’t heard him. His left wrist was banded, and the screen glowed under his sleeve. He still held the big steel mixing bowl against his hip. It had spilled a little on the way. There were two Snickers lying in the grass behind him. His face was a stranger’s face, gray and set and old, and he was breathing in short hard gasps.
“Don’t give it to her,” he said. “Not yet. Not here. Not where they can see.”
“Dad—”
“Listen to me.” He pulled me three steps away, out of the knot, into the shadow of the maple, and he put both hands on my face. They were shaking. They smelled like candy wrappers and porch light. “Jonah. Look at me. I’m going to say this once, and I need you to hear it all the way to the end.”
“Dad, they—he’s dead , Mr. Pruitt—”
“I know.”
“They shot him—”
“I know. I know. I saw. Jonah.” His thumbs pressed into my cheekbones. “This is what I want you to do. You hear me? We’re on the same clock. Both of us. I’ve got a band, and you’ve got a band, and whatever else is true, I’m not going to be able to stand next to you every second of this. Do you understand? There are too many people. It’s too big. There’s going to be a point where I can’t be next to you.”
“Then I’ll stay with you—”
“No. You’re going to stay with your friends.” He said it fiercely. “You’re going to stay together, the five of you, and you are going to look out for each other, and you are going to think , because you’re the smartest kid I know, and you’re the best one, and I mean that. Priya is going to run the numbers. Wren is going to run. And you’re going to be the one who holds it together. That’s what you do.”
“I can’t—”
“You can.” He leaned his forehead against mine. For a second, we just stood like that, with his breath in my face. Then he tilted the bowl, and he began to pour.
Full-size bars. Snickers and Kit Kats and orange-wrapped Reese’s cups, tumbling out of the steel into my white pillowcase in a heavy gleaming stream. Twenty, thirty, forty. I heard the band on my wrist chirp, over and over, a bright insistent bird.
“Dad. Dad, stop —”
“Half,” he said. “I’m keeping half. I’m not stupid, Jonah. I’m not going to just—I’ll be fine. I’ve been fine for forty-six years. Let me do this one thing.”
“I don’t want —”
“I know you don’t.” He set the bowl down in the grass, with a small clink. His face was wet, and I realized he was crying and trying not to let me see. “I know you don’t. That’s why I love you. Now listen. Here’s what we do. Every half hour, after the tally, if I can get to you, I’ll come to our porch. Our porch, the fixture, the one that works. If you can get there, you come. If I’m there, we’ll see each other. If I’m not—” He stopped. “If I’m not there, you keep moving . You don’t wait. You don’t come looking. You keep moving , and you stay alive. Promise me.”
“Dad—”
“Promise me.”
I looked at him. I looked at the grass-stained knees of his jeans and the little dent in his nose where his glasses sat. I looked at the porch light behind him, which he had spent forty-five minutes fixing, and which was dark now, as dark as every other porch on the street.
“I promise,” I said.
“Good boy.” He kissed my forehead, hard, the way he had when I was six and afraid of the dark. “Now go. Go find Kofi.”
I turned my head. Dess was already running.
She’d dropped her crow mask somewhere. She was sprinting down the middle of Alder Street toward the black mouth of Sumac Court, with her pillowcase clutched to her chest and her sneakers slapping the wet road, and the whole neighborhood was surging around her, in the opposite direction, toward the houses, toward their bowls, toward anything. Wren swore, and took off after her. Priya followed, clutching her clipboard like a shield. Theo wiped his face with a mustard-striped sleeve and ran, lumpy and absurd in his hot-dog suit, the bun bouncing at his shoulders.
“Jonah!”
Hazel was waiting for me at the corner. She had one hand extended, palm up. The fairy lights on her wings flickered and settled, and in the middle of all that wreckage, in the middle of the screaming and the dark, she looked like the only warm thing left in the world.
“Come on,” she said. “Come on. We’ll get him. Come on .”
I took her hand.
The band on my wrist glowed green in the dark. 03:57:12. Behind me, my father was already turning away, bowl against his ribs, heading for the Okafors’ porch and the other houses beyond it, and I did not watch him go, because I knew that if I did I would not be able to leave.
“Hazel,” I said, as we ran. I don’t know why I said it. Maybe I needed to say something that was true. “You’re going to be okay.”
“I know,” she said. She was already breathing hard. Her wings were catching the wind behind her like a sail. “Just—whatever happens tonight. Promise we stay human. Okay? Whatever it takes. We stay human .”
“I promise.”
“Say it.”
“We stay human.”
She squeezed my hand. We ran together into the dark between the streetlights, with the drones turning slowly overhead like a slow black wheel, and the red fence humming in the sky, and a hundred and nineteen small green clocks counting down on a hundred and nineteen small pale wrists.
We were thirty yards from Sumac Court when the first scream of the night came that wasn’t fear.
It came from behind us, from the middle of Alder Street, and it was an old woman’s voice, high and furious and cracked. I turned my head. I couldn’t help it. Under the dead porch light of number nineteen, a red wagon stood in the road, the laundry basket in it heaped with candy, and a big man in a pirate’s coat stood over a small figure in a witch’s hat, who was on her knees on the pavement with her arms wrapped around a bowl.
Mrs. Dolan was shouting at him. She was shouting and swinging the bowl, and toothbrushes flew everywhere in a bright, ridiculous rain.
“I’m sorry, Dolly,” said Gary Kessler, quite clearly, across the street, in the voice of a man apologizing for a late payment. “It’s nothing personal.”
And he brought down his plastic hook.
End of Chapter One
Comments