Author's Preface
7:30 to 8:00 PM — Fun Size
00:28:41
Priya Nair did her best thinking in kitchens.
I don’t know why. She had a theory that it was the smell of other people’s lives, the dish towels and the half-read mail, the fridge magnets, the evidence of someone else’s ordinary Tuesday, and that it made her feel as though the world still had rules. She had solved her first regression problem at her grandmother’s kitchen table in Edison, New Jersey, at the age of nine, over a plate of cold aloo paratha. She had decided to apply to Carnegie Mellon at fourteen, in the middle of a debate about whether a hot dog was a sandwich.
So when she said, “I need a kitchen,” on the front lawn of number fourteen, with a dead woman’s hat riding down the street on top of a wagon of candy, none of us laughed or asked why.
“Inside,” I said. “Now.”
“Jonah—” said Wren. She was staring down the hill. The red wagon had stopped at the Alvarezes’ lawn, and Gary Kessler was bending over something small and still, and the squeak of the axle had gone quiet. “He’s going to come up here. You know that. He waved.”
“He waved.”
“He waved , Jonah. Like it was a—like we were—”
“I know what it was.” I turned her by the shoulder, gently, away from the street. “He’s got a hundred people to rob. We’re not special yet. Inside. Please.”
She let me. I think she was grateful to be told.
We went in through the front door, all of us at once, in a clumsy knot, and I shut it and threw the deadbolt and put my back against the wood. The house smelled like it always did. Coffee, laundry soap, pine floor cleaner, and under it the faint metallic tang of the shop, which clung to my father’s clothes and, by extension, to every room he had ever stood in. There was a pair of his work boots by the mat. A mug on the hall table with a ring in the bottom. A neat stack of ungraded quizzes, held down with a stapler.
Something in my chest turned over, very slowly, like a key in a lock.
“This way,” I said, and my voice came out too loud. “Kitchen’s back here.”
7:34 PM
It was on the counter next to the toaster.
I hadn’t seen it when I went through that kitchen at six o’clock to look for a lighter for the pumpkins. I hadn’t seen it because it hadn’t been there. It sat square and gray and anonymous between the bread box and the fruit bowl, as if it had always been part of the furniture, and the little green lamp on its lid blinked at a slow steady pulse, like a resting heart.
HOUSEHOLD ALLOCATION. ALDER ST. 14. 2 RESIDENTS. 44 PIECES.
“Forty-four,” said Theo. “That’s you and your dad. Twenty-two a head.”
“I know.”
“Did he open it?”
“I don’t think so.” The seal on the lid was whole, a thin strip of clear plastic with a serial number. My father had not been home since the drones came. He had been standing on the porch with a mixing bowl in his arms and a hundred decisions in his head, and I realized, with a small, awful flash of love, that he had never once thought of the thing sitting in his own kitchen. He had given me every candy bar he owned, and it had not crossed his mind that he had a second supply behind the door.
I broke the seal and lifted the lid.
Forty-four fun-size bars lay in neat rows under a sheet of clear film, Snickers and Twix and Milky Ways in their small shiny wrappers, glinting in the overhead light. There was nothing else in the case. It had no manual, no card, no nothing. But Priya had come up beside me and taken the lid out of my hands, and she turned it over, and held it up to the window.
“There’s writing,” she said.
There was. On the underside of the lid, printed in a small, clear, businesslike sans-serif, no bigger than the type on a pill bottle:
ALLOCATION AVAILABLE 19:00–20:00. UNCLAIMED UNITS WILL BE RECOVERED AT 20:00. NO FURTHER ALLOCATION WILL BE ISSUED.
Nobody said anything.
“Eight,” said Dess finally. “Eight o’clock. That’s the next tally.”
“It says units ,” said Priya.
“What?”
“Units. Not pieces. The label says forty-four pieces , and the lid says units . They don’t use the same word.” She turned the lid over and over in her hands, with a small rapid frown. “They wouldn’t do that by accident. Whoever wrote this is careful . The band says CANDY, and the case says PIECES, and the fine print says UNITS. Three different words, and if they’re careful, one of them is the real one.”
“Which one?”
“I don’t know yet.” She set the lid down on the counter with a click. “I need a scale.”
“A what?”
“A kitchen scale. Digital. In grams. Does your dad bake?”
“He’s a shop teacher,” I said. “He’s got three of them. He weighs flour like it’s going to explode.”
I got it from the pantry, a flat black digital scale with a stainless-steel tray, left over from the winter my father decided to learn sourdough, and she put it on the island and switched it on. It lit up with a soft blue glow. Zero grams. She took a single fun-size Snickers out of the case and laid it on the tray.
17 g.
“Okay,” said Priya. “Okay. Everybody give me your bands.”
“My band ?” said Theo.
“Not to take off. Obviously. I want you to hold your wrist out. I need to watch a number change.”
She pulled the kitchen whiteboard off the fridge. It was my father’s, the one with the grocery list on it and a half-erased note that said CALL DENTIST in his careful block capitals. She wiped it with the heel of her hand. She took a dry-erase marker, uncapped it with her teeth, and in the manner of a person who has found the only thing in the world that makes sense, she began to draw a table.
It took her twenty-one minutes.
I watched all of it. I think we all did. We stood around that kitchen island like a family around a birthday cake, and Priya stood in the middle of us in her cardboard cat-box, with the cat ears sliding down over one eyebrow, and she did something that I have never seen anybody else do, which was to be ruthlessly, joyfully, purely curious in the middle of a nightmare.
She emptied her pillowcase onto the counter and zeroed her band by putting the empty case back on her wrist. It gave her a flat 0. Then she put in one fun-size Snickers.
CANDY: 1
Two.
CANDY: 2
She did it five times, ten times, with Snickers and Twix and Milky Ways and Three Musketeers, and every time it went up by exactly one. Then she tried a fun-size bag of Skittles. It went up by one. A fun-size pack of Smarties (the little ones, a roll no longer than a finger) went up by less . The number didn’t change at all. She added a second. It ticked up.
“Half,” she said. “It rounds. Two Smarties is one. It’s keeping a decimal.”
She wrote it on the whiteboard. Smarties = 0.5. Under it she wrote: grams?
She weighed the Smarties. 9 g. She weighed a Milky Way. 17. A Twix, 18. A bag of fun-size Skittles, 16. A Starburst, 10 , and the band, when she fed it a dozen, ticked up by six and a half.
“It’s weighing,” she said. “Oh, God, it’s only weighing. It doesn’t care what it is. It’s grams. Roughly one unit per seventeen grams. A unit is a fun-size bar.” She looked up. Her eyes were bright and wet and terribly alive. “That’s what they mean by units . The unit of the whole game is a fun-size bar . It’s the name of the thing . He said it on the sky. He said it .”
“That’s sick,” said Wren.
“I know.”
“That is so sick.”
“I know! Isn’t it? It’s a pun. It’s a pun with forty bodies in it.”
She went on. She weighed a full-size Snickers from my father’s bowl, which I had brought in, in my pillowcase. 52 g. The band, when she dropped it in, jumped by three. Then she weighed a full-size Reese’s, the two-cup pack, 42 g , and it rose by two and a half. A king-size Hershey’s, 43 . A bag of M&Ms the size of a paperback, three hundred grams , which my father had picked up on sale, and which she held in her hand for a long moment as if it were a bomb. The band went up by seventeen.
“Seventeen,” she said. “One bag is seventeen people’s worth of fun size.”
“That’s why I’m nine,” I said.
“That’s why you’re nine. That’s why you were always going to be nine, the second he started pouring. Your dad didn’t give you a head start. He gave you a different currency .”
“What does that mean?” said Hazel.
She had come in last, with Mia, and had been standing in the doorway to the living room with the child on her hip. She hadn’t said a word since the porch. Her face was drawn and pale and utterly composed. There was a streak of brown dye down one cheek where a wing had rubbed against her, and the fairy lights on her back had dimmed to a faint, fitful glow.
“It means,” said Priya, “that there are two ways to be rich. You can have a lot of little things, or you can have a few big things. Light things and heavy things. And the game has been built to make the heavy things worth the most per hand. Because you can only carry so much.”
She paused.
“They don’t have to make us rob each other,” she said slowly. “They could just have counted. But they didn’t count. They weighed. Which means you can’t hide big numbers in your pocket. You have to carry the mass . And the more you carry, the slower you are, the more you stand out, and the more you tempt anyone who’s watching.”
“Don’t say any more,” said Theo. “I’m going to be sick.”
“I’m not done .”
7:48 PM
The rest of it came out in a long, rapid, shaking flood, and it ran across my father’s whiteboard in a handwriting that grew steadily smaller and more furious until she was writing in the margins.
“There are a hundred and nineteen people,” said Priya. “Well, there were . The allocation is twenty-two units a head. That’s two thousand six hundred and eighteen. That’s the case money, that’s the official candy. Then there’s everything people already had. The haul from trick-or-treating before seven. I’d say another fifteen hundred. Two thousand, if people are generous. Then the full-size stuff, which is heavy, so maybe another five hundred, because half the street has been handing out bars like your dad. Call it five thousand, six thousand units, in the whole neighborhood, all in. That’s everything .”
“Okay,” said Wren. “So?”
“So at eight o’clock the cases go away.”
She stopped. She tapped the whiteboard with the cap of the marker, three times, a hard staccato.
“The cases are the only new candy in the game. That’s the lid. No further allocation will be issued. After eight o’clock, there’s nothing coming in. Not a unit. The whole neighborhood’s a closed bag, and every piece in it is in somebody’s hands or in somebody’s house. After that, the only way to get one more unit is to take it from somebody else.”
“That’s the point,” said Dess quietly. “Isn’t it? It says that. He said taken .”
“It’s not just that. It’s that it’s zero-sum . Every unit that goes up on my wrist goes down on someone else’s. Do you see it? It doesn’t matter how rich the neighborhood is. It matters who has it. The cut is relative . They don’t kill you for being poor. They kill you for being poorer than the people around you. Which means the only way not to die is to make sure someone else is poorer than you.”
“Priya.”
“And every time five people die, the line moves up, because there are fewer of us and the same amount of candy. The average gets richer. The poor get squeezed. By the last tally, there’ll be, I don’t know, sixty-some people and six thousand units and the bottom five will be rich . They’ll be rich and dead. And everyone’s going to be carrying so much that there’ll be no way to walk.”
She laughed, a thin cracked bark. “It’s designed. It’s so well designed . It makes the early rounds easy and the late rounds impossible. It starts you out feeling safe. Don’t you see? That was the first tally. They give you the first half hour to feel like it’s just a game, and then they pull the floor out.”
“That’s what Dad said,” I said. “The bottom is going to get hungry.”
“Your dad’s a smart man.”
“I know.”
Hazel had put Mia down on the living-room couch. I could see them through the arch. She had pulled my father’s old afghan over the child’s legs, and she was kneeling beside her, with her chin on the armrest, as if she were trying to see the world from a five-year-old’s height. I didn’t hear what they were saying. I only saw Mia’s small face turn, once, toward the kitchen, and look at us with an expression I couldn’t read.
“What do we do?” said Theo.
“We use it,” said Priya.
“Use it?”
“We use the fact that we know. Nobody else is going to figure it out in time. They’re running around the street grabbing every piece of candy they can carry, and they don’t know why. They don’t know about the eight o’clock lid. They don’t know about the weights. We do. So we do the opposite of what they’re doing.” She wrote in the margin of the whiteboard, in square capital letters:
1. TAKE THE ALLOCATION. ALL OF IT. BEFORE 8:00.
2. FULL-SIZE ONLY. WEIGHT, NOT COUNT.
3. HIDE IT.
“Hide it where?” said Wren.
“Anywhere. Anywhere the band doesn’t reach. It only counts what’s on you. It said : pillowcase or person. A stash isn’t counted. It’s safe. It’s unmeasured . We hide the heavy stuff, and we carry only what we need, and before the tally, we top up from the stash.”
“And then everybody sees us coming out of the woods carrying two hundred units,” said Wren.
“Not two hundred. We only need to be over the cut. I’ve got a model. The cut at the second tally is probably twelve or fifteen. At the third it’s going to be thirty. Fourth, fifty. We don’t have to be rich . We have to be above the line , and the line is a lot lower than anyone thinks.”
“That’s clever,” said Theo, in a small, awed, miserable voice.
“That’s terrible ,” said Priya, and her voice cracked. “I hate it. I hate that it works.”
“There’s one more thing,” said Dess.
Everyone turned.
Dess was standing at the window over the sink with her back to us. She had pushed the blind aside with one finger, and was looking out at the dark street, at the fog and the drones and the long thin shape of the red wagon, which had begun, very slowly, to move again. Her voice was flat.
“The numbers went white,” she said.
“What?”
“Before the tally. At the end. I was looking at my band, and about a minute out, the numbers went white. All the digits. They stopped changing. I watched them. Hazel was trying to put the child’s hat right, and I put a Milky Way in Kofi’s pocket, and the number didn’t move.”
Priya went very still.
“A minute,” she said.
“I think. Sixty seconds. Maybe.”
“It locked,” said Priya. She was breathing fast. She turned to the board and put the marker to it, and then took it away again, as though the idea had gone off like a flash in front of her. “Oh my God. It locks . It takes a snapshot. At T-minus sixty seconds the count freezes, and anything you add after that doesn’t count. Whatever you’re holding when the lock falls is what they measure. Not at the tally. A minute before . You can’t top up. You can’t be saved at the last second. Nobody can run up to you with a pillowcase and throw it in your arms. It has to be on you at 7:59 on the dot.”
“Then how is anyone supposed to—” began Theo.
“They’re not. That’s the whole point. It’s the drama . Somebody who waits till the end, who’s counting on a rescue, who thinks there’s time—” She wrote it on the board, in capitals so big the marker squealed:
LOCK AT T-60.
Then she underlined it, twice.
“Nobody knows,” she whispered. “Nobody knows that, do they? They think they have until the tally. They’re going to be up there at 7:59:50 shoving candy in their kids’ pockets, and it won’t count .”
The house was very quiet.
“We have to tell them,” said Hazel.
She was standing in the arch to the living room. I hadn’t heard her come up. She still had one hand on the doorframe, and the other pressed flat against her stomach, as though to hold something in.
“We have to tell them,” she said again. “Everyone we can. Right now. Before eight.”
“Hazel,” said Wren.
“It’s information , it doesn’t cost us anything—”
“It costs us the only edge we’ve got.”
“It costs us—” Hazel stopped. She looked at the whiteboard, at the long ugly arithmetic of it. “There’s a little boy out there who’s going to be standing on a porch at 7:59 stuffing his pockets, and it won’t count. And his mother’s going to watch.”
“Maybe,” said Wren. “Maybe not.”
“Maybe not,” Hazel agreed. “Maybe that’s you .”
She turned her head. She looked at each of us, and I saw her do the arithmetic, in the plain unhurried way of a person who has already done it in her head and has simply been waiting for permission to say the answer aloud.
“I’m going to start telling people,” she said. “I’m going to go door to door. You can come if you want.”
She went to the kitchen table, where the ruined moth wings lay folded on a chair, and she picked up Mia’s small orange hat.
It was 7:51. We had nine minutes.
7:51 PM
We did the stash in ninety seconds.
Wren found the place, because Wren found places. My father kept an old chest freezer in the garage, a white Kenmore the size of a coffin, where he stored venison from his brother-in-law’s hunting trips in tidy butcher-paper bundles with the dates written on in marker. She flung up the lid and a gust of frozen air rolled out around our knees. “Here,” she said. “Under the deer.”
“That’s my father’s—”
“He’ll forgive me.”
We emptied the case into a freezer bag, forty-four units of fun size, and then I opened my pillowcase and counted out the heavy things. Full-size Snickers. Kit Kats. The two big Reese’s packs and the three-hundred-gram bag of M&Ms that was worth seventeen people. I kept back sixty units, a fat, comfortable cushion that a thief would have to work for, and I put the rest, a hundred and fifty or so, into a plastic bin and shoved the bin down the side of the freezer, behind the frozen bundles with their neat dates. Elk, Nov. 2022. Deer shoulder. I covered it with a layer of ice. I shut the lid. I stood there for a moment with my hand flat on the cold white metal, and the thought came into my head, absurdly, that it felt like closing a casket.
“You’re sure about this,” I said.
“No,” said Priya. “I’m sure it’s better . That’s all I can be.”
We split what we had left. Wren took forty. Dess took her own, and Kofi’s. Theo took thirty and did a little shuffle of misery. Priya took twenty-five, and then, after a look at Hazel, who stood in the garage doorway with the sleeping weight of a child on her shoulder, ten more and pressed them into Hazel’s pillowcase without a word.
“I don’t need—” said Hazel.
“You do. You’re at seventy-seven. You’re going to be standing in the road telling strangers about a lock , and if you don’t have a margin, someone’s going to walk up to you and take the whole pillowcase while you’re talking.”
“Priya.”
“Don’t ‘Priya’ me. Say thank you.”
“Thank you.”
“You’re welcome. Go.”
We went.
7:53 PM
I have thought a lot about that walk.
Not about what happened. About what we thought was going to happen, as we went down the porch steps in the cold dark, the six of us and the small boy and the small girl, because we had a plan, and a plan, in the first hour of a thing like that, feels like a coat in a blizzard. It feels like you might live. Hazel went first. She had pulled the brown shawl of her moth costume tight around Mia and was walking fast, down the middle of the sidewalk, with her head up and her ruined wings trailing behind her like a torn flag. Theo followed, because Theo followed Hazel anywhere. Then me. Then Priya, still clutching her clipboard, talking quietly to herself.
Wren and Dess were taking the long way, around the back of the houses, with Kofi between them. Wren had the pipe. Dess carried nothing. It was her job, she said, to carry nothing, because she was the one who could run.
The first house was the Garritys’.
Pastor Lyle Garrity ran the little Methodist church at the end of Sumac Court, a soft-spoken man with a gray ponytail and a crooked smile, who gave a homily every Halloween on the theology of Reese’s Pieces. He was standing on his porch with his wife Joanna, in matching cardigans, holding hands. They had the look of two people who had been standing there since seven o’clock, waiting for a bus.
“Pastor,” said Hazel, breathless. “Mrs. Garrity. I’m sorry to bother you. We have—there’s a thing about the tally. It locks.”
She said it fast, in a rush, the words spilling out of her, at one minute before, it locks, you can’t add anything after, whatever you’re holding at 7:59 is what counts , and when she finished she was crying a little, and had to wipe her nose on Mia’s hat.
The Pastor listened to all of it. He nodded slowly. When she was done, he looked at his wife, and then at us, and he said, very gently, “Thank you, child.”
“Do you understand? You have to—”
“I understand. I do. It’s a great kindness.” He squeezed his wife’s hand. “We’ve decided, Joanna and I. We talked about it, while the lights were out. We gave ours to the Finnegan children, the little ones. Every piece. They were so scared.” He smiled. “I don’t think we’ll be needing the lock.”
“Pastor Garrity—”
“It’s all right, dear.” He reached out and touched her shoulder, and his hand was warm. “The best thing we can do is not be afraid. Go and tell the others. Quickly. That’s what’s needed.”
We went. I looked back once. They were still standing there on the porch with their hands joined, under the dead light, two gray heads, close together, looking out at the dark. I didn’t know it yet, but I would remember them better than almost anybody.
7:55 PM
The next three houses went like that.
There was a young couple at the Hendersons’ neighbor’s, the Raos, who thanked us and actually wept, and ran back inside, and we heard them yelling to each other through the window about the lock. A teenager at number twenty-six, a kid named Josh Whitaker who sat behind me in Spanish, stared at Hazel and then at me and said, “You’re lying,” and then, after a pause, “No, you’re not,” and started running. An old woman with a walker, at the end of Birch, didn’t understand a word of it, and nodded and smiled and patted Hazel’s cheek.
And there was Avery Pohl.
I should tell you about Avery. He was sixteen. He was the kid whom Danny Kessler had once held upside down over the bleachers, and he had spent the following two years being a small, bitter, sharp-tongued boy who sat at the back of every class with his arms folded and a look on his face as though he had personally been sold a bad used car. He lived with his stepfather at the corner of Alder and Birch. He was sitting on his front steps with his pillowcase in his lap when we ran up, and he looked at us with exactly the same expression.
“It locks at one minute,” Hazel said. “The tally. At 7:59. You have to have it all on you before then. Please.”
“Why would you tell me that?”
“Because—”
“No. Seriously. Why?” He stood up. He was a head shorter than me, and thin, and his eyes were small and hard and entirely without trust. “You’re Pike. You’re the one with all the candy. Everybody knows. Colt Kessler’s been telling people for twenty minutes.”
“I’m trying—”
“You’re trying to trick me. You want me to put my candy in my pockets and then someone’s going to take it. That’s what this is. It’s a setup .”
“It’s not a setup,” said Theo, desperately. “Dude. Avery. I’ve known you since second grade. I let you copy my science fair board.”
“You let me copy it because you were scared of me.”
“I was seven .”
Avery Pohl looked at Theo. He looked at the little girl asleep on Hazel’s shoulder, and the bright tear tracks on Hazel’s face, and for an instant I thought I saw something shift in him. A small gate, far back, opening a crack. Then he shook his head.
“Nobody does anything for free,” he said. “I figured that out a long time ago.”
He went inside and locked the door.
“Avery!” Hazel was pounding on it with her fist. “Avery, please—”
“Hazel.” I took her wrist. “We have four minutes. We can’t.”
“He’s sixteen .”
“I know. I know he is.”
She pulled free. She stood with her forehead against the door, and then, abruptly, she stepped back. She wiped her face with her sleeve. “Okay,” she said. “Okay. I can’t save everybody. I know that. I’m just—” She drew a ragged breath. “Nobody should have to be that alone.”
7:56 PM
We found the Kesslers on the porch of the Pruitts’ house.
I didn’t want to go near it. I don’t think any of us did. It lay at the bend in Birch Lane, a small tidy ranch with a wheelchair ramp and a wind chime made of old spoons, and on its front lawn, in a little puddle of floodlight that the drones had never turned off, lay Walter Pruitt. They hadn’t moved him. His cap was still beside him. His wrench was still where it had rolled. A thin dark stain had spread under his head and hardened in the cold, and the fog hung over it, and someone had put a dish towel over his face.
Danny Kessler sat on the porch steps with his back against the rail.
His arm was in the scarf-and-hockey-stick splint that Hazel had made, held across his chest, and his face was the color of candle wax. A fine sheen of sweat covered his forehead. His pillowcase lay in his lap. It was empty. It had been empty since the people in the road finished with it, and he was holding it in his good hand like a child holding a dead pet. Beside him on the step, with his knees drawn up to his chin and his hood pulled down over his eyes, sat Colt.
Wren, who had arrived first with Dess and Kofi, stood in the yard with the pipe hanging at her side. She had not gone any closer. She looked up as we came round the hedge, and her eyes said very clearly: I did not start this.
“They’re at three,” she said. “Danny’s at three units. Colt has nothing. His band says zero.”
“They were robbed ,” said Theo.
“They were robbers,” said Wren. “It’s not the same thing.”
“It’s the same now.”
Hazel had already walked to the porch. She stopped on the bottom step, with Mia’s weight against her, and looked up at the two boys. Colt peered out from under his hood. His face was streaked and swollen. He looked about nine years old.
“Where’s your dad?” said Hazel.
“He left.” Danny’s voice was a croak. “He went to do the south end. He said stay here. He said he’d be back before eight. He’s got the wagon, he’s—he told us to wait. He said he’d fix it.”
“Did he give you any candy?”
“He said he’d fix it.”
Hazel closed her eyes for a moment. When she opened them, she was looking at me.
I knew what she was going to say. I had known since the corner of Birch Lane, since a single Reese’s cup went into the pocket of a boy who had tried to crack my skull. I had known since a small girl in a pumpkin costume laughed in the gutter. I could feel it coming at me, huge and quiet and inevitable, like a train in a tunnel.
“Jonah,” she said. “You have sixty.”
“I know what I have.”
“I’m not going to ask you.”
“You just did.”
“I’m not going to ask you,” she said again, steadily, “because you already know the answer, and I want you to be the one to say it.”
“Hazel,” said Wren. “He tried to kill Kofi.”
“He tried to take Kofi’s pillowcase. And you broke his arm for it. We both did the thing we had to.” Hazel did not raise her voice. “I think we stop now. I think that’s all we get to do. We don’t get to go on and on being the people who were right.”
“You’re going to get someone killed,” said Wren.
“Maybe. But not him.”
I looked at Danny. He was looking at his own knees. He had heard every word, and in all of it, he hadn’t moved, hadn’t spoken, hadn’t even looked up. I thought of his hands on the hockey stick. The big cheerful idiot grin he used to wear in the hallway. Avery Pohl dangling by his ankles. Mrs. Dolan’s toothbrushes, scattered in the road like confetti.
I opened my pillowcase.
“You get thirty,” I said.
He lifted his head.
“Thirty units. That’s eight full-size bars. It’s enough that you’re safe at the next tally. It’s not a gift. It’s because Hazel asked. If you ever come at us again, I’ll take it back, and I won’t be gentle.”
His mouth opened and closed. He looked at the candy. He looked at me. And then, as though every muscle that had held his face together for the last hour had been cut at once, he began to cry. It wasn’t pretty. It was a hoarse, helpless, shaking sob, deep in the chest, like a child’s, and Colt put his arms around him, and the two of them folded together on the step like paper.
“I’m sorry,” said Danny, through it. “I’m sorry. I’m sorry. I’m sorry —”
“I know,” said Hazel.
She knelt and counted the bars into his pillowcase one by one, with her free hand, and the band on his wrist chirped each time. Eight. Then she did the same for Colt, from her own supply, fifteen units, not much, her face set. She did not look at Priya, who had made a small anguished noise. The numbers on the boys’ wrists climbed.
CANDY: 33.
RANK: 78 / 114.
It was 7:57:40.
“Now listen,” said Hazel to both of them, very clearly. “It locks at one minute before. 7:59. Whatever you’re holding then is what they count. So you keep it. Don’t put it down, don’t trade it, don’t give it to anyone, not even your dad. Do you understand? Put it in your pocket and don’t take your hand off it. Promise me.”
“I promise,” said Colt.
Danny nodded. He couldn’t speak.
And that is when the wagon came round the corner.
I heard it first, as I had heard it every time: the long dry squeak of the axle. It came from the far end of Birch Lane, steadily and without hurry, out of the fog. Then I saw it. The red Radio Flyer, with its laundry basket heaped high. The tricorn hat. The long black coat. And Gary Kessler, walking behind it with the handle in his fist, as unhurried as a man out for a stroll on a Sunday.
There was something wrong with his face.
It took me a moment to see what. He was not looking at his sons. He was looking at the porch, at the two of them huddled together on the step, at the pillowcases in their laps, and at us, standing in the yard in a ragged semicircle with a girl in a moth costume and a girl with a length of steel pipe. And his expression was perfectly polite. It was the expression of a man who has come home to find his neighbors on his lawn and is deciding, courteously, what to do.
“Dad,” said Colt, in a small voice.
“Evening,” said Gary Kessler.
He came on through the gate. His wagon rolled up the walk, past the dish-towel-covered body of Walter Pruitt, and stopped at the foot of the steps with a faint metallic sigh. He took off his hat. He tucked it under his arm. He stood looking down at his elder son’s splinted arm, and at the pillowcase in his lap, and at the number on the band.
“Who broke your arm, son?” he said.
“Dad—”
“I asked you a question.”
“I did,” said Wren.
She said it flat, and cold, and loud. She had not moved. She stood in the yard with the pipe hanging at her side, and the white light of the drones lay along her shoulders and on the wet black braid down her back. “I broke it. He came at us with a hockey stick. He was going to take a kid’s bag. I’d do it again.”
Gary Kessler turned his head and looked at her.
He looked at her for a long time, with those small, patient, quiet eyes, and I felt something prickle on the back of my neck, as though a draft had found the crack in a door. He didn’t move. He didn’t raise his voice. When he spoke at last, it was almost kind.
“You’re the Castillo girl,” he said. “Your father fixes transmissions on Route Nine.”
“Yes, sir.”
“He did mine, once. Good man.” He nodded, slowly, to himself. “That’s a shame.”
He turned back to the steps.
“Danny. Where did you get that?”
He was looking at the candy. Eight full-size bars, fat and glossy in the white light, stacked in the bottom of the pillowcase like gold. Danny drew his arm tighter across his chest.
“They gave it to me,” he said.
“Who did?”
“The—Pike. Pike did. And her. Hazel. They said it was—I couldn’t—Dad, it was gone , everything was gone, they took it all, I was at three, I was going to die —”
“And they gave it to you.”
“Yes.”
“Just gave it.”
“Yes, sir.”
Gary Kessler looked at me. Then at Hazel. And I saw it: something moving behind his face, like a slow hand on a clock. Calculation. He was adding, the way he had been adding since the first tally. I watched the numbers run, and I saw the very moment the answer came out.
It was pride.
Not anger. Not even suspicion. It was the pride of a man who has never in his life taken something he did not pay for, and who has just discovered that his son has done it in front of him.
“We don’t take charity,” said Gary Kessler.
“Dad—”
“Miss.” He turned to Hazel. He took the hat out from under his arm and held it against his chest, with a small bow. “I appreciate it. I do. It’s a kind thing. But I’m going to ask you to take it back.”
“Mr. Kessler—”
“The boys and I will see to ourselves.”
“Mr. Kessler, listen to me.” Hazel took a step toward him. She was shaking. “There’s a thing about the band. At one minute before the tally it locks. It freezes the count. Nothing after that counts. If you’re planning to top him up at the end, you’ll be too late. It has to be on him now . You have a minute.”
He heard her. I saw it. I saw the words go in, and settle, and be weighed.
“Thank you, miss,” he said. “That’s very interesting.”
“It’s true —”
“I’m sure you believe so.” He smiled. It was a gentle, sad, indulgent smile, the smile you give a child who has told you the moon is made of cheese. “The President said the band tallies on the half hour. Nobody said anything about a lock. I think it’s a theory. And I think you’re a bright young lady who’s seen a lot of bad things tonight.” He put his hat back on. “Danny, give the girl her candy.”
“Dad—”
“I said give it back.”
“Dad, I can’t—”
“Danny.”
There was no threat in it. There was nothing in it at all. It was the voice of a father who has said a thing and expects it to be done, and Danny Kessler, who was seventeen and six foot two and had a broken arm, sat on the porch steps with his mouth working and the candy in his lap, and then slowly, as though pulling a splinter, he took the eight bars out of his pillowcase and laid them on the step beside Hazel’s foot.
The band on his wrist chirped, and dropped.
CANDY: 3.
“There,” said Gary. “Thank you, children. Now we’ll be on our way.”
He turned the wagon.
“Mr. Kessler,” I said. “The clock.”
00:01:41.
7:58 PM
It was a minute and forty-one seconds, and I have never known time to do what it did then. It stretched. It went thin and bright and slow, like something being pulled out of a fire.
“Yes,” said Gary Kessler. “I see it.”
He had not turned around. He stood at the foot of the porch steps with his hands at his sides and his back to us, and the great dark spread of his coat hung from his shoulders like a curtain. In front of him, on the top step, his two sons sat with their faces turned up.
“Mr. Kessler,” said Priya.
She had not spoken since we left the house. She came forward now, out of the fog, small and bedraggled in her cardboard box, and held up her clipboard in both hands like a shield. The ink on it had run in the damp. “Sir. I watched my band at the first tally. At sixty seconds, the numbers went white. They froze. I’m not guessing. I’ve tested it. I tested everything. It’s real. Please. If you have a plan to top him up from the wagon, it has to be now .”
“You’re a bright girl,” said Gary. He still did not turn. “You’re Raj Nair’s daughter. I know your father. He does my taxes.”
“Mr. Kessler—”
“I do my own arithmetic,” he said. “It’s my one good talent. I have been counting candy on this street since seven o’clock. I counted it in every kitchen. I counted it in every bowl. I counted who had a lot of it, and who had a little, and who was going to hold on to it, and who wasn’t. I counted you , miss, and I counted your friends. And I counted my sons.”
He turned.
He looked at all of us, slowly, in the white floodlight, the way you look at a table before you sit down to a meal. His face was calm. His eyes were bright and steady and they were the eyes of a man who was entirely, completely, utterly sure. It was the most terrifying thing I had ever seen.
“My boys will not be taking a handout from the people who broke my son’s arm,” he said. “I will not have it said that a Kessler took charity on the worst night of his life. I will top him off myself, from my own wagon, the way I planned. A father sees to his own. And if your lock is real, which I doubt, I will have lost nothing that I wouldn’t have lost anyway.”
“That doesn’t make sense ,” said Theo.
“It makes perfect sense.”
“It’s eight bars , they’re right there, he could pick them up in two seconds, you could pick them up—”
“I know,” said Gary Kessler. “And I won’t.”
He took a single step forward, up onto the first stair, and stood between his sons and the little pile of fat bright wrappers on the porch, and as he did, I saw the small, dreadful truth of him at last. It was not cruelty. It was not greed. He was a proud man in a dark place who had decided, hours ago, that he knew the only way out, and he was going to walk it to the end even if it killed him.
“Dad,” said Danny. His voice cracked. “Dad, please. Please. Just let me—”
“Stay where you are.”
“Dad—”
“I said stay where you are, son.”
00:01:02.
I could hear my own heart. I could hear Hazel, beside me, breathing in short, harsh, whistling gasps, like a woman climbing a mountain, and I heard her whisper, “no, no, no, no,” under her breath. Wren had taken a step toward the porch, the pipe half raised. Dess caught her by the sleeve.
“Don’t,” said Dess. “It’s not about the candy.”
“He’s going to—”
“I know what he’s going to.”
00:00:58.
And I saw the white come.
I had been watching my own wrist, and it came like frost spreading across a windowpane. A fast, silent, creeping paleness. Every digit on my band turned from green to white, one by one, left to right, and froze. CANDY: 33. RANK: 61 / 109. I looked at Hazel’s. The same. I looked at Danny’s, where it sat on his pillowcase in his lap, a pale cold glow in the dark.
CANDY: 3.
He was staring at it. He was staring at it with his mouth open and his eyes wide, and I saw the knowledge go into him, like a nail into wood. He lifted his head. He looked at his father. He opened his mouth to speak.
“Dad,” he said. “Dad. It’s white.”
“It’s a fault ,” said Gary.
“Dad. It’s frozen. It’s not changing. Dad, look—”
“It’s a fault , son, it’s nothing—”
He knew. I saw it. He knew in the instant it happened, in some bone-deep, animal place that had nothing to do with arithmetic, and his hand went down into the wagon like a drowning man’s. He came up with a fistful of candy, a double handful, a wave of it, and he flung it into the pillowcase in his son’s lap, and another, and another. A cascade of wrappers. Snickers and Twix and Milky Ways, fun size, full size, pouring over Danny’s knees and spilling down the step and the walk and the grass. Colt was shouting. Gary was shouting. He was shouting wordlessly, a deep animal sound without shape, and with both arms he scooped up the whole basket, the wagon’s whole heaped weight, and he tipped it over his son’s head.
The band on Danny’s wrist did not change.
CANDY: 3.
RANK: 108 / 109.
8:00 PM
It was a tone, again. A sustained bright bell-note rising from every wrist on the street.
I don’t remember what I did. I remember that Hazel had dropped to her knees on the porch step, and that she was trying to pull the candy up out of the gutter, with both hands, scrabbling at it. I remember my own voice saying her name. I remember Wren’s arm hooked around my chest, holding me back from something, and that I had not noticed I was moving.
TALLY COMPLETE.
The lights came down.
Five white cones, from five drones. This time I did not look at all of them, because I could not. I saw only the one on the porch, where Danny sat with his father’s whole stolen mountain heaped over his knees. Then the farther ones, in the corner of my eye, blurred by the fog. A pair of small gray figures on a porch at the end of Sumac Court, holding hands. A thin dark shape in the open doorway of a corner house, with a pillowcase in his hand. And a heavy man in a fleece vest, lying on his side at the foot of a pair of porch steps in a yard strewn with children’s bikes, with a woman bent over him, screaming.
A voice came from the sky. It was kind.
“ Joanna Garrity. Lyle Garrity. Avery Pohl. Walter Henderson. Daniel Kessler. ”
A pause.
“ Thank you for your service to the future. ”
The applause came again, soft as rain, and the ice in the glasses.
I saw the Garritys go. I will say it plainly, because they would have wanted it said plainly: they went well. The band on Joanna’s wrist lit red, and she turned to her husband and said something I couldn’t hear, and he bent his head and kissed her on the forehead, and the black threads ran up their arms together, branching, racing, and met somewhere near their hearts. They sat down side by side on the porch swing. His hand was still in hers. A moment later, the swing began to move, gently, in the wind.
I saw Avery Pohl. He had come out onto his front step with his pillowcase in his fist, and in the floodlight he was very small. He looked at his wrist. He looked up at the drone. I think he said something. I think it was, but I kept it , and I think that was true, because I’d seen the bag, it was full. It had been full since seven o’clock, and he had held it against his chest so tightly that when the lock fell, there was no room to carry any more. But it hadn’t been enough. Somebody else had had more. Somebody else always had. The black thread reached his heart, and he sat down on his front step with his pillowcase in his lap and his chin on his chest, and he never moved again.
And I saw Danny.
He did not scream. I’d thought he would. He lifted his good hand, very slowly, and looked at it, and then at the band, which was glowing red, and then he looked at his father. Gary Kessler had gone down on both knees in the wreckage of his own wagon, and he had one arm around his son’s shoulders, and the other hand pressed flat on his chest, as if he could hold the thing inside him by force.
“It’s all right,” said Gary. “It’s all right, Danny. It’s all right. It’s going to be—”
“Dad,” said Danny.
“I’m here.”
“Dad, there was one in my pocket.”
He was fumbling, with his good hand, at the front of his hoodie. The black was already past his elbow. His fingers weren’t working properly. He got them into the pouch, finally, and pulled out something small, and orange, and crushed. A Reese’s peanut-butter cup, in its little crinkled wrapper, a single piece.
“She put it there,” said Danny. “Hazel. When I wasn’t looking. I found it.” He laughed, a small bright broken sound. “It’s only one. It’s not even—it wouldn’t have made a difference. It’s two and a half. But I thought—I thought I’d tell her. Somebody ought to tell her. It was nice.”
He looked at Hazel.
She was on her knees on the step, three feet away. Her face was a wreck. She had both hands over her mouth.
“It was nice,” said Danny Kessler. “Thank you.”
The red went into his eyes. His head tipped back against his father’s arm. And the little orange wrapper slipped from his fingers and rolled slowly down the step and came to rest at Hazel’s knee.
No one spoke.
It was Colt who broke it. He had been sitting very still beside his brother, his hands in his lap, and he looked at the empty hand and the red band and the half-open mouth, and he made a sound that I will never describe to anyone. Then he threw himself across his brother’s body, and held on, and howled.
Gary Kessler did not make a sound.
He knelt in the ruin of his wagon, with his son in his arms, and he stared out at nothing. His eyes were open and perfectly dry. Slowly, with a kind of terrible tenderness, he put one big hand over Danny’s face, and he closed the boy’s eyelids with his thumb.
“The numbers went white,” he said.
His voice was perfectly ordinary. It was the voice of a man commenting on the weather.
“You told me,” he said. He did not look up. “You stood on my son’s steps and you told me. And I said, ‘I’m sure you believe so.’”
“Mr. Kessler,” said Hazel. She had her hand out. It was shaking. “Mr. Kessler, I’m—I’m so—”
“Don’t.”
He lifted his head.
He looked at her, and I saw it all go by in his face, quite slowly, one thing after another, like a train going past in the night. Horror. Grief. The dreadful blank of a man who sees the shape of the mistake he has made. And then, behind it, rising quietly and without hurry, like water coming up in a cellar, something else.
“You were right,” he said. “You said it nicely. You said it so nicely , miss. And you were right. And that’s the thing I’m never going to be able to forgive.”
“I didn’t—”
“I know you didn’t. I know.”
He laid his son down on the boards of the porch. He did it carefully. He straightened the splinted arm across the chest. He took off his tricorn hat, that stupid, preposterous pirate’s hat, and he laid it over the boy’s face, and he stood up.
He was very tall, I realized. I had never noticed. He stood on the porch of Walter Pruitt’s house in the glare of a floodlight, a huge man in a black coat with a broken plastic hook hanging from one sleeve, and he turned and looked at each of us in turn. At Hazel, with her ruined wings and her empty hands. At Priya, who had put the clipboard over her mouth. At Wren, and the pipe. At Dess, who stood in front of her brother with her arms spread.
And at me.
“Pike,” said Gary Kessler.
“Mr. Kessler—”
“Your father taught my son shop. Did you know that? Two years. Said he was good with his hands.” He said it in the same gentle, ordinary voice. “I’d like you to tell him something for me. I’d like you to tell him I won’t forget it.”
“Forget what?”
“Everything.”
He bent. He took the handle of his wagon. It was a ruin now: one wheel buckled, the basket slewed, the whole heaped treasure of candy spilled into the grass and the gutter and the bloodstained walk. He didn’t look at it. He picked up the little tricorn hat, set it carefully on top of the wreck, and began to pull.
“Colt,” he said.
Colt lifted his face from his brother’s chest. It was swollen and wet and lost.
“Get up, son. Bring what’s left.”
“Where are we—”
“There’s a bridge on Creek Street.” Gary was speaking to no one now, to the dark street, to the drones. “It’s the only way across to the south end. All the houses down there, all the ones nobody’s touched. Every soul on this street who wants to get at them has to pass over it. I’m going to stand on it.”
“Dad—”
“I’ve been stupid,” said Gary Kessler. “I’ve been polite. I’ve been fair. I’ve let people keep what’s theirs and I’ve taken only what I needed.” He began to walk, with the wagon squeaking behind him. “That’s done. From now on, everybody pays.”
Colt hesitated a long moment, looking down at his brother. He bent and kissed Danny’s forehead, through the brim of the hat, with a short, hard, desperate movement, as if he were afraid he would not be allowed. Then he got up and followed his father into the fog. The squeak of the wheel went with them, thin and rhythmic, down Birch Lane, until it was gone.
8:03 PM
I don’t know how long we stood there.
The floodlights had gone out. The drones had pulled back to their stations, and the fog had thickened. A dozen small sounds drifted up the street: a woman keening, a man calling a name, someone trying to start a car that had no gas. Far off, a long, hollow, rhythmic banging, as if someone were beating on a door with a fist.
Hazel sat on the step with the little orange wrapper in her hand.
She had picked it up. I don’t think she knew. She was turning it over and over between her fingers, smoothing the crinkled foil, flattening it against her knee. Mia had woken at some point and was standing at her side, in the pumpkin hat, with her small hand tucked into the folds of the moth’s ruined shawl. She did not ask what had happened. She looked at the porch, and the man in the hat, and the boy lying beneath it, and she said very quietly, to no one, “One, two, three.”
“Hazel,” I said.
“Eight bars,” said Hazel.
“Hazel.”
“They were right there . I had them in my hand. I put them down because he told me to. I could have just—I could have—”
“You couldn’t.”
“I could have pushed him. I could have knocked him over, I could have taken Danny and run —”
“He’s a foot taller than you. He’d have—”
“I don’t care .” She was not crying. That was what frightened me. She said it flatly, almost conversationally, and her eyes were dry and very wide. “I don’t care what he would have done. I stood there and I let him do it. I watched .”
“He chose,” said Wren.
“He didn’t choose. His father chose. Danny was seventeen. He was begging .”
“Hazel.” I knelt in front of her. I put my hands over hers, over the little orange wrapper. They were icy. “Look at me. You did everything. You did everything anyone could have done. You gave him thirty units. You warned his father. You told him. He wouldn’t listen. That isn’t yours.”
“It is, though.”
“It isn’t.”
“It is mine ,” said Hazel, and she looked up, and I saw it in her face, the thing that had been a spark at the drain at 6:44, and a flame in the kitchen, and was now something else, something quieter and harder and stranger. “If I’m going to do this, if I’m going to stay the way I said, I have to carry it. That’s what it costs. That’s the whole cost. If I put it down, I stop being anyone.”
She closed her fingers around the wrapper.
“I’m going to be okay,” she said. “Give me a minute. I’m going to be okay.”
I sat down on the step beside her. After a moment, Theo sat on her other side. Then Priya, and Dess, with Kofi in her lap, and Wren last, still holding the pipe, looking out over the dark street with an expression I couldn’t read. We sat in a row, six kids and two small ones, on the porch of a dead man’s house, with the stained boards of a second dead man between us and the road. Nobody said anything. We were just there. It was the closest to prayer I’ve ever been.
“Jonah!”
It was a man’s voice, hoarse and breaking, from up the hill. I knew it before I turned.
He came running down the middle of Birch Lane out of the fog, with his gray sweater torn at the shoulder and his glasses crooked on his nose. He was holding the steel mixing bowl against his hip, and there was nothing in it. As he came into the light, I saw his face, and I thought: I have never seen my father cry. But I had. Once, in the hallway of the old house, the night my mother left. I was nine. I had forgotten that. He had been standing very straight with his hand on the banister, and the tears had simply been running down his face as if he hadn’t known.
He dropped to his knees in front of me, in the wet grass, and gripped my shoulders.
“You’re all right,” he said. “You’re all right. You’re all right.”
“I’m all right, Dad.”
“I was at the Hendersons’. Walt—” His voice cracked. “Walt couldn’t stand. He’d put his back out carrying the twins down from the roof. He was sitting on the porch and he had eleven units and I gave him mine, I put them in his lap, every piece I had on me, and I told Marguerite to hold the kids and I—it was the last minute. It was the last minute, Jonah. I put them in his lap . The numbers went white and I looked at them and nothing—nothing—”
“I know.”
“I watched him—”
“I know , Dad.”
“I killed him,” my father said. “I was too late. I didn’t know. If I’d known—”
“You couldn’t have known.”
“You did.”
The words hung in the air between us. I felt the whole weight of it settle over me. I had known. We’d all known, in a kitchen, at 7:51, and we had spent nine minutes saving the people we could reach and lost the ones we couldn’t. I saw him understand that. I saw it cross his face, and I saw him decide, in the way of a man who has spent his life deciding what to do with other people’s grief, that this one would be his.
“Then you did what you could,” said my father. “And so did I. And that’s all there is.”
He pulled me against his chest. I felt his heart beating, quick and light and uneven, like a bird in a box.
Over his shoulder I saw the drones come down.
They came in silence, from every direction, out of the dark above the rooftops, a hundred small black shapes gliding in on the fog.p They went house to house. At each door, one hovered, and a claw reached in through the open windows, through the doorways, and lifted out a small gray case. It rose with a faint, steady hum. Fifty cases. Eighty. A hundred. They went up into the dark in a long silent procession, a river of gray boxes hung from black wings, and the lamps on them blinked green, slow and regular, like the heartbeat of some enormous thing.
ALLOCATION CLOSED.
The words were in my band. They were on every band on the street. They hung there a moment, white on black, and then they faded.
00:29:43
REMAINING: 109
“It’s closed,” said Priya, in a hollow voice. She was staring up at the vanishing boxes. “Now it’s closed. Now there’s nothing new. There’s only us, and what we’re holding. Every unit we get from here on is a unit someone else loses.”
Nobody answered her.
Far away to the south, so faint that at first I thought I had imagined it, a sound began. A thin, dry, rhythmic squeaking. A wheel, in need of oil, going steadily down a dark road. It went on for a little while. Then it stopped.
I don’t know how I knew. But I knew it the way you know, in the dark, that someone has finally chosen where to stand.
End of Chapter Three
Comments